Another Bolsup as top nurse but not a professor helps media blame Scottish Government for private care home neglect

Some more selective reporting by the Herald’s David Bols attempts to attribute responsibility for the Skye care home covid-19 outbreak to the Scottish Government allowing NHS Scotland to discharge elderly patients back into care homes, before tests have confirmed that they are covid-19 free. Chief Nursing Officer, Professor Fiona McQueen did, but only in passing, remind Brewer that care homes should be isolating the returnees until the results are in. She forgot to mention that the care home owners are responsible for providing the staff with PPE to ensure they do not spread the virus.

The Skye care home failed its last inspection and infection control problems were highlighted:

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/2020/05/03/private-skye-care-home-with-mass-outbreak-had-weak-staff-team-and-inadequate-infection-control-when-inspected-in-november-and-january/

Two of the other homes owned by the company which owns the Skye care home have had several covid-19 deaths:

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/2020/04/21/remind-me-who-is-responsible-for-infection-control-procedures-in-privately-owned-care-homes-where-glen-campbell-says-there-have-been-mass-deaths/

McQueen, in a stumbling and confused performance which had Gordon Brewer pulling some faces, did help with the campaign to exonerate the private care home owners. She is now the third senior health adviser to potentially weaken the Scottish Government’s reputation after both Leitch and Calderwood’s tendency to follow the Westminster line and to make gaffs, drew a media feeding frenzy. Of course, the recent polls tell us that the public is not so easily fooled.

This is not the first time, I’ve been less than impressed by ‘Professor’ McQueen. A few years ago, she appeared on Reporting Scotland to report on far too many nurses having a lack of commitment to the job and poor standards. It turned out her conclusions were based on wandering around a few wards in the course of her duties. There was no survey, there was no sample, no methods, only anecdotes.

McQueen, like Leitch, is not a real professor. She’s just another NHS manager who is awarded a professorship when her health board becomes associated with a local university. They don’t need to be able to pass a Year 2 research methods module never mind have published research in peer-reviewed journals. I need to lie down now.

One thought on “Another Bolsup as top nurse but not a professor helps media blame Scottish Government for private care home neglect”

  1. I’m disappointed there’s so much hostility addressed to the public health people during the current crisis. I’ve seen Jason Leitch dismissed for being ‘a dentist’ a few times, as if there’s something wrong with being a dentist and being a dentist somehow negated his experience and expertise in public health. He was in fact a lecturer in dentistry.

    And now here’s Fiona McQueen being dismissed because she’s not an academic. I’d love to know if she actually claimed on Reporting Scotland to be offering an academic study of nursing standards. As for her views being based on “wandering around a few wards in the course of her duties”, it would be good to know how you reached that conclusion.

    I’m all for calling people to account for what they do wrong in the course of their duties, but it’s a bad day when they get tellt aff for not being what they don’t claim to be.

    As for the title of Professor, in my job in a local authority education department, on trips to Germany I got used to be called ‘Frau Doktor’. I quite liked it in fact. But I accepted the title as a mark of my seniority (not to say my advanced age) and gave it up as soon as I got home.

    Like

Leave a Reply to rantingoldbagsblog2 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.