The research informing the Aberdeen ‘slaughterhouse’ hospital claims is deeply flawed, suffers from inadequate sample size, selection bias, lack of transparency and unacceptable levels of subjectivity in analysis
In the Guardian, yesterday: A senior surgeon has called for a criminal investigation into a Scottish hospital after it emerged that at least 19 patients had died from avoidable complications due to surgery. Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, said he had repeatedly reported concerns about the hospital’s liver and pancreatic surgery from 2021 onwards and believed dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily there. and: Two external experts who carried out the review in 2022, surgery professors at Edinburgh and Leeds universities, concluded the “extremely high” death rate at Aberdeen between 2017 and 2020 ran as … Continue reading The research informing the Aberdeen ‘slaughterhouse’ hospital claims is deeply flawed, suffers from inadequate sample size, selection bias, lack of transparency and unacceptable levels of subjectivity in analysis
The dark side of BBC Scotland drama choices – Shetland has only a third of the Scottish average crime rate and it’s falling while it’s soaring in the even more scenic Highlands due to English drug gangs
I do watch the above crime series and now worry about the recovery of Tosh. I realise it’s fiction but it’d be better located in Inverness and the Highlands where crime is soaring due to English County Lines drug gang violence. See more on that below. Why is Shetland a strange choice? See these data: Source: https://www.gov.scot/publications/recorded-crime-scotland-year-ending-june-2026/documents/ Wouldn’t this be better choice of location? BBC Scotland production editor – ‘Interesting, could we just make the gang members from Glasgow?’ Continue reading The dark side of BBC Scotland drama choices – Shetland has only a third of the Scottish average crime rate and it’s falling while it’s soaring in the even more scenic Highlands due to English drug gangs
How can there be a ‘slaughterhouse’ hospital in NHS Grampian, the health board with the lowest number of malpractice claims per head in all of Scotland?
When I began the search for the data to produce the above graph, revealing NHS Grampian to have the lowest number of malpractice claims per 10 000 population, against in it, in all of Scotland, I had no idea what to expect. I’ll admit that I hoped it would not reveal NHS Grampian to have the highest level by far, to reinforce the media coverage today, with 7 out of 8 ‘Scottish’ front pages like this: This is one of the most dishonest pieces of media reporting in some time. A personal dispute between medics turned, for profit and to … Continue reading How can there be a ‘slaughterhouse’ hospital in NHS Grampian, the health board with the lowest number of malpractice claims per head in all of Scotland?
Swinney firm on centre-left as new ‘mansion tax’ bill is launched
In the Independent today, the above and: Scotland is moving closer to introducing higher council tax charges on homes worth more than £1m, with the Scottish Government publishing legislation to create two new bands for high-value properties. The Council Tax (High Value Dwellings) Bill proposes additional council tax bands for properties valued at more than £1m and £2m, which are currently grouped together in the highest existing band. Deputy First Minister and Finance Secretary Jenny Gilruth described the publication of the bill as an “important milestone”, saying the proposals would make the tax system fairer and help fund local services. … Continue reading Swinney firm on centre-left as new ‘mansion tax’ bill is launched
80 year-old sexually abused – Just one more shocking example of how privately owned care homes are cash cows where the profit motive will result in mass deaths in the next pandemic
From BBC Scotland today the above and: A man has told BBC News how his elderly mother, who was suffering from dementia, was sexually assaulted by a fellow resident in a care home in Inverclyde. The man – who we are calling John to protect his mother’s identity – said the “horrific” sex attack took place despite concerns previously being raised by staff about the behaviour of the attacker. John told the BBC he was speaking out after HC-One, which operates the Merino Court Care Home in Greenock, admitted liability and paid damages after a civil action. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cw5y1r557j54o ‘HC-One‘ reminded … Continue reading 80 year-old sexually abused – Just one more shocking example of how privately owned care homes are cash cows where the profit motive will result in mass deaths in the next pandemic
IDENTIFYING A PROBLEM ISN’T HARD
By Mark E. Saunders of “The Scottish Minuteman” https://www.facebook.com/profile.php/?id=61575625542197 Perhaps a little context would be helpful before anyone starts to slap the Labour Party on the back for ‘discovering’ a problem. Under successive SNP governments, Scotland has created; a free university tuition system, expanded both Foundational and Graduate apprenticeship, invested in programmes like ‘No One Left Behind – which has supported more than 111,000 young people since 2019. And the progress from these actual Scottish government actions can easily be calculated: Measured nine months after leaving school, positive destinations for Scotland’s youth have increased from 85.9% in 2009-10 to 93.5% in 2024-25 — that’s … Continue reading IDENTIFYING A PROBLEM ISN’T HARD
The slaughterhouse of journalism – hysterically politicising a staff dispute in an Aberdeen hospital with only 0.07% higher mortality – hogwash!
Fast and perceptive as you like, MSM Monitor has responded to the above stories with: There is more to the NHS Grampian story than the BBC is reporting. This 2019 tribunal includes two of the doctors featured by BBC Scotland in recent days. Each is in opposing camps. Allegations of racism and discrimination. Are vendettas at play here? https://x.com/msm_monitor/status/2123388743860314566 I’ll take advantage of the space in a blog to elaborate a bit, hopefully helpfully. The above two NHS Grampian medics referred to, appear in more detail in this 23 September 2019 Employment Tribunal report: with this judgement: When we dig … Continue reading The slaughterhouse of journalism – hysterically politicising a staff dispute in an Aberdeen hospital with only 0.07% higher mortality – hogwash!
These three North American ferries are still in service though between 30 and 45 years older than the age deemed old by corporate media in Scotland
From the Alaska Beacon in July 2026, the above and: A Louisiana shipbuilder is proposing to build a replacement for one of the workhorse vessels in the Alaska state ferry fleet. Thoma-Sea Marine Constructors LLC submitted a bid of about $350 million to build a replacement for the 62-year-old Tustumena, one of two ocean-going ships in the fleet, the Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities said Tuesday. https://alaskabeacon.com/2026/07/02/shipbuilder-submits-bid-to-replace-an-iconic-but-aged-alaska-state-ferry/ 62 year-old? The media operating in Scotland often refer to a 30 year figure as a point at which ferries should be replaced and make much of the fact that 4 … Continue reading These three North American ferries are still in service though between 30 and 45 years older than the age deemed old by corporate media in Scotland
OUTRAGEOUS – Two English police forces arrested women for ‘illegal’ abortions in 2026 but there has not been one such arrest in Scotland for at least 60 years!
From the Scottish Greens yesterday: It is “outrageous” that Scotland is now the only country in the UK that hasn’t decriminalised abortion, the Scottish Greens have said. The UK Government announced earlier this week that women who have been convicted of, or cautioned for, an abortion offence relating to their own pregnancy will be pardoned. In Scotland, abortion remains potentially a common law crime if performed outwith the provisions of the Abortion Act 1967. https://greens.scot/news/outrageous-scotland-now-only-country-in-uk-that-hasn-t-decriminalised-abortion This is just political posturing. A wee bit of research would have helped. In the Guardian 16 March 2026: Vulnerable women in England still being … Continue reading OUTRAGEOUS – Two English police forces arrested women for ‘illegal’ abortions in 2026 but there has not been one such arrest in Scotland for at least 60 years!
How Scotland’s Covid Test & Protect system integrated within existing, experienced public health teams in local authorities, succeeded while England’s privatised system ‘cost lives’
The Covid Inquiry on Test & Trace convenes today: Headlining BBC Breakfast this morning and in the Independent, the above and: Campaigners have branded the UK’s [sic] Covid-19 test and trace mechanism an “abject failure”, ahead of a major new report into pandemic response measures. Baroness Heather Hallett, chairwoman of the UK Covid-19 Public Inquiry, is set to release her latest findings on Thursday, evaluating the strategies deployed to curb the spread of the virus. https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/abject-failure-covid-19-test-000133000.html Yes, no, NHS Scotland gets no mention and you can be sure the media operating in Scotland will either ignore this or use the … Continue reading How Scotland’s Covid Test & Protect system integrated within existing, experienced public health teams in local authorities, succeeded while England’s privatised system ‘cost lives’
