Scotland’s national clinical director’s ‘worrying’ arithmetic

National clinical director Jason Leitch, today:  “The Chief Scientific Adviser in England has said he thinks 20,000 deaths across the UK would be a good outcome. In Scotland, that would be about 2,000, but the worst-case scenario is much worse than that. People need to take the advice they’re being given very seriously.” Scotland is neither 10 % of the UK nor is it any simple percentage of it. First, Scotland’s population is only 8% of the UK so even if we accept the premise, that would be 1 600 deaths. Second, it is already clear that NHS Scotland is saving … Continue reading Scotland’s national clinical director’s ‘worrying’ arithmetic

If it was the other way round they’d report it

Wales has half the population of Scotland yet, now, almost twice as many coronavirus deaths. Were it the other way round, we’d hear about it. 12 deaths in 347 means a rate of 36 per 1 000, twice the Scottish rate of 19 but still below the English average of 49. The Labour Party has been dominant in Wales for at least 70 years now and has run government there for 20. NHS Wales is the manifestation of the competence or otherwise of the Labour Party. Like the Labour Party in Scotland, they have betrayed their supporters. On many counts, … Continue reading If it was the other way round they’d report it

Herald platforms Tory plan to spread coronavirus infection more widely

Leaving aside the astonishing brass neck required for Miles Briggs to call himself the Shadow Health Secretary, the Herald letting him talk unchallenged about a crisis in social care in Scotland, beggars belief. Don’t they read about the all-too-real crisis in social care in Tory England? See this from the Guardian last June: The government’s failure to get to grips with the escalating financial crisis in social care has put tens of thousands of older and disabled people at risk of being denied basic support such as help with washing and dressing, care chiefs have warned. Without urgent guarantees over … Continue reading Herald platforms Tory plan to spread coronavirus infection more widely

Coronavirus: How the UK Government did not listen to the WHO

From sam: It seems possible, and perhaps probable now, that UK government policy, followed by the Scottish and other UK governments, has been fatally flawed when dealing with covid19. That is the opinion of Professor Anthony Costello, former Director of WHO who has a piece in the New Statesman.Here is an extract. “Marc Lipsitch and colleagues, from Harvard and Nanjing universities, report that between 10 January and 29 February Wuhan hospitals faced on average 637 intensive care unit patients and 3,454 serious inpatients every day. Instead, be like Guangzhou, the largest province in China, where strict disease control measures were … Continue reading Coronavirus: How the UK Government did not listen to the WHO

Glasgow’s super hospital one of cleanest and safest in UK?

There seems to be no clear record of where Scotland’s 7 coronavirus fatalities took place. Looking back through media reports, I think the figure is 2. Greater Glasgow and Clyde has 110 cases. If 2 have died that gives a ratio of 18 per 1 000 cases. Last night the Scottish average was 19 per 1 000, the UK average was 49 per 1 000 and the figure for Italy a few days ago was more than 80! So, contrary to all the guff, we and they have suffered at the keyboards of BBC and Herald health correspondents, Anas Sarwar … Continue reading Glasgow’s super hospital one of cleanest and safest in UK?

Coronavirus Update: The Miracle of NHS Scotland

The UK total death toll increased by an appalling 53 in one day to reach 233. In sharp contrast there was only 1 further fatality, to reach 7, in Scotland. The UK mortality rate is now 47 in 1 000 cases while in Scotland it is 19 in 1 000 cases. The almost 3 to 1 ratio has been constant now since the first deaths. With more than 5 000 cases hospitalised across the UK, it is clear that something is happening here or perhaps I should say, is not happening, in Scotland. I won’t revise the possible explanations again. … Continue reading Coronavirus Update: The Miracle of NHS Scotland

Why the anaesthetist might be wrong about positioning of hand-sanitisers

From [the learned] stewartb: Quite a lot published on the significance of location of hand sanitisers in hospitals for levels of usage by visitors. From a very quick and non-expert root around the literature, I’m not sure this consultant’s point about sanitisers near the main entrance to the hospital is necessarily supported by evidence. For example: Hobbs et al (2016) Visitor characteristics and alcohol-based hand sanitizer (AHS) dispenser locations at the hospital entrance: Effect on visitor use rates. American Journal of Infection Control Issue 3, 258-262  https://www.healthdesign.org/knowledge-repository/visitor-characteristics-and-alcohol-based-hand-sanitizer-dispenser-locations These authors conclude that the placement of an AHS dispenser in a lobby … Continue reading Why the anaesthetist might be wrong about positioning of hand-sanitisers

BBC Drivetime can’t wash its hands of this scare story

Yesterday we heard, repeated: ‘Now as the number of coronavirus cases continues to rise in Scotland, concerns [sic] have been raised over hand hygiene at the nation’s biggest hospital. A senior doctor who works as a consultant anaesthetist in the hospital says the supermarkets are doing the better job in ensuring people sanitise their hands than the NHS.’ So it’s the concern, singular, of one medic. No other medic has come forward. She visited two areas and waited for ten minutes. One supermarket was wiping the trolley handles. I’ve been in three recently with no sign of that. So, not … Continue reading BBC Drivetime can’t wash its hands of this scare story

Herald bringing you the news where you don’t live and of medical shortages there too

This is not a Scottish story. It has no Scottish content. No Scottish medic is present in it. BBC UK are hot on the trail of this story: BBC Scotland have nothing on this so you can be sure there’s nothing to be had. The Herald had a go at this last week but with their evidence based risibly and only on comments in a Facebook chat hosted by one GP: https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/2020/03/13/heralds-irresponsible-and-unreliable-journalism-as-coronavirus-worries-grow/ Continue reading Herald bringing you the news where you don’t live and of medical shortages there too