Merchant banker and Jack McConnell ‘thinktank’ writer in unsurprising attack on NHS Scotland under SNP

Sir Ewan Brown

Sir Ewan Brown, above, retired merchant banker and Church of Scotland Assembly member, currently writing for Sir Jack McConnel’s Enlighten think tank is in the Herald today with:

Scotland’s health service is a “colossal and complex behemoth” overseeing nearly £20 billion of public money without proper scrutiny, one of the country’s most senior business figures has warned.

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.wordpress.com/wp-admin/post.php?post=115983&action=edit

The report is barely 2 A4, utterly devoid of evidence (not one source), an uncalled for opinion piece from a past-it non-academic, justifying an attack on key principles with unacceptable pro-Labour critique including:

should dental and ophthalmic services continue to operate free to all at the point of contact?  
should free prescriptions be continued for all and free access to consultative services offered under General Pharmaceutical Services through the Minor Ailments Service?

https://www.enlighten.scot/nhs2048/managing-reform-sir-ewan-brown/

This is an un-referenced hit job on behalf of Labour and offering nothing of use to policy makers in Scotland. and not the first time that McConnel’s no-thought-tank has sought to deceive us on behalf of his Union:

Rt Hon Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale’s thinktank tries to hide entirely English culture of County Lines drug gang ‘cuckooing’ plague in Scotland

Regulars here will recognise the rarely enlightening thinktank headed up by Lord McConnell, Chris Deerin and their totally non-academic, guide-leader, BBC average housewife interviewee, Research Director, Alison Payne.

Today, they have the above and:

The recent passage of a new criminal offence of cuckooing within the Crime and Policing Act marks a significant milestone after years of sustained advocacy by the Centre for Social Justice and Justice and Care. It is a reform grounded not in theory, but in the lived experience of some of the most vulnerable individuals across the UK.

Cuckooing, sometimes described as “forced home invasion”, occurs when criminals take over the home of a vulnerable person and use it for illegal activity, often drug dealing or exploitation. Victims are frequently targeted because of addiction, poor mental health, disability, or social isolation. What begins as manipulation or grooming can quickly escalate into coercion, intimidation and, in some cases, violence.

For Scotland, the implications are particularly important. While cuckooing has often been associated with urban “county lines” activity in England, evidence suggests it is a growing issue across all communities, including in Scotland. Its impact extends beyond individual victims to neighbours and local areas, bringing anti-social behaviour, intimidation and wider community harm. https://www.enlighten.scot/cuckooing-recognising-a-hidden-crime-and-the-challenge-for-scotland/

You might think this ‘growing issue’ is growing among Scots but it’s not. It’s a ‘spreading issue’ and English-born enforcers arrive in Scotland from cities in England to implement cuckooing culture here.

In the Inverness Courier in 2025 but with not a peep from the local BBC folk, far less those at Pacific Quay:

English drug gangs are targeting vulnerable Highlanders with increasing ruthlessness amid a rising tide of drug-related violence, exploitation and abuse. Latest figures in a 24-page Police Scotland performance report for the north division’s Highland area show a marked increase in drug supply offences for the year 2024/25.

The new data shows that in 2024/25 there were 178 offences, a rise of 34 on the previous year. Within the report, the human cost locally is highlighted with ‘cuckoo-ing’ – where criminals take over the home of a vulnerable person to store and deal drugs in county lines activity – highlighted as a favoured tactic.

The report highlights how Highland children, as well as vulnerable adults, were being used by the violent gangs.

https://mailchi.mp/c1c24e9b1f97/gangs-target-vulnerable-highlanders-amid-rise-in-drug-offences?e=ff16de8436

The County Lines gang plague is everywhere in Scotland from Caithness to Dumfriesshire. It’s entirely ‘based’ in England. It’s being reported by tabloids and local press but ignored by BBC Scotland, STV, the Herald and the Scotsman. It’s to blame for the stubbornly high drugs death rate in Scotland.

This is a clear agenda based on an editorial edict to avoid narratives damaging to the reputation of the Union.

Imagine drug gangs based in Scottish cities were active in this way across England, the media coverage and the political rants against us.

Finally, cuckooing (taking over vulnerable people’s homes) has roots in the mid-2000s in England, linked to crack house closures displacing dealers, who then targeted vulnerable locals. It became strongly tied to county lines post-2015. 1 It built on earlier drug dealing patterns but scaled with mobile phone technology, exploitation of vulnerable people/children as runners, and tactics like cuckooing for bases. Major English hubs (London, Birmingham, Liverpool, Manchester, etc.) are frequently cited as sources. 2

Sources:

  1. https://pure.manchester.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/345706436/Beyond_the_Line_Final_Report_-_White_Version_.pdf
  2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/County_lines_drug_trafficking


Discover more from Talking-up Scotland

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

8 thoughts on “Merchant banker and Jack McConnell ‘thinktank’ writer in unsurprising attack on NHS Scotland under SNP

  1. Who funds Lord Jack-the-Lad’s ”Think” tank ?

    Is it Labour ? Is it Westminster ? Is it some of Labour’s very anonymous donors ? Is it friends of Joani Reid’s husband’s Chinese chums ? Is it the Security Services’ anti-Scotland department ?

    Like

  2. Scottish Gov spends £22Billion funding SNHS & social care. 1/3 of the budget spend.

    The Tories cut NHS funding for over ten years. Until the pandemic spent £270Billion over 2 years. UK Gov Accounts. The Scottish Gov has to mitigate the Tory cuts. Scotland did not receive £27Billion over Covid. Pro rata parity.

    Westminster has wasted £Billion on HS2 and Hinkley Point etc. Years late and over budget. Loans borrowed from China. Scotland has to pay back monies on loans not borrowed or spent in Scotland. £Billions which could be better spent on healthcare, education and growing the Scottish economy. Scotland has lost £Billion because of Brexit. Scotland did not vote for Brexit.

    The Scottish Gov has funded proper rehab facilities, £250million over 5 years. MUP has reduced alcohol consumption. The unionists opposed it. The drug/alcohol consumption is on the decline. Cocaine and ketamine are now the drugs of choice. Less fatal than opium based. People are recovering and leading better lives. Proper total abstinence rehab facilities give people a better chance of survival.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. So the sharks are circling, or compradors as I prefer to call them. The Scottish Health Service is not privatised enough. Big Pharma and private health companies are missing out on – checks article comments – a £22 billion bonanza. Intolerable!

    Think tanks exist to provide plausible sounding reasons for passing legislation that benefits the oligarchs who fund them. Then policy is passed by the politicians they’ve bought.

    I would advocate taking public services and private monopolies, including land, back into public control. Is there a think tank developing policy for that?

    Like

  4. “Merchant banker and Jack McConnell ‘thinktank’ writer in unsurprising attack on NHS Scotland under SNP”

    First In heard of this story or is it ?

    Liz S

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Sir Ewan, whom I know well, does have previous.

    This from a letter to The Herald in November 2025:

    “… NHS Scotland has 22 separate boards, several hundred board members, over 160,000 staff and an annual budget of £20 billion (around 40% of Scotland’s total budget).

    “The Auditor General has regularly called for stronger governance, comprehensive financial plans, system redesign, and transparency to manage the increasing pressures on NHS Scotland’s public funds and ensure value for money.

    “The Cabinet Secretary for Health owes the Scottish public an assurance that either the failings of the minnows are not replicated across the NHS whale; or if they are, what he is doing about it.”

    Was ever thus from auditors, one of which I was also myself a very long time ago.

    The best description of auditors appearing with wise words after-the-event is that they “bayonet the wounded”.

    Like

  6. Rather than two sides of A4 (which I agree was the limit of The Herald on Sunday’s coverage) there will be a self-published book to follow by Sir Ewan, called Gvrnnc Disemvowelled: Why Do Politicians and Public Officials Only Pay Lip Service to Good Governance?

    His previous self-published book, Corporate Ego, at the end of 2021, was critical of many of the 34 listed Scottish companies that had vanished in the previous 40 years, explaining with some case studies failures of governance in corporate boardrooms.

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.