A decade’s perspective in just four graphs – A&E waiting times performance

Scotland’s health secretaries

By stewartb (In-depth Correspondent)

I’m obliged to the Royal College of Emergency Medicine (RCEM) for publishing extended period time series data on A&E waiting time performance for the four NHS organisations across the UK. It does so in a graphical form that enables a valuable, perhaps novel perspective to be gained.

We know that much attention is given to A&E waiting times, especially in Scotland. Each weekly release of statistics (only monthly updates provided in England) gets Reporting Scotland’s ‘crisis’ treatment if the figures show any drop in performance. This has been going on for years!

Typically, the BBC’s output for a Scotland-based audience on this – and indeed other health service issues – provides little or no context or perspective. How often does the BBC provide a comparison between A&E or any aspect of NHS performance in Scotland with that in another UK nation where it would leave a relatively favourable impression of NHS Scotland or the Scottish Government with its audience? Negative framing is the norm!

However, as I trust this post will illustrate, ‘perspective’ can be easily provided – if the desire is there to do so! And the outcome can be illuminating!

A decade’s perspective

The source information for this post can be found here https://rcem.ac.uk/data-statistics/

The RCEM graphs shown below are for performance against the benchmark 4-Hour waiting time target in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland over the past decade or so. Red horizontal lines on each graph have been superimposed on the originals at the 90% and 75% levels. This is done both to clarify the labelling on the Y axes and to compensate for the different scales used by the RCEM: it helps ‘correct’ for any misleading visual impression that may otherwise be given. The vertical blue line on each graph is set as close as the RCEM originals permit to a mid 2011 date, again to aid comparisons.

I suggest focusing on two features: (i) the overall amount of time over the decade or so that each graph records a performance ABOVE the 90% level; and (ii) the overall amount of time each graph records a performance BELOW the 75% level. By visual inspection alone, and on both factors, NHS Scotland performs best by in some cases by a substantial margin.

End note
There’s really not much more to say about these data! But perhaps two wider points are worth making.

Firstly something that BBC Scotland’s editors and journalists might consider: providing ‘perspective’ (and context) in news and current affairs programmes should be seen as a basic public service and it’s not that difficult to do – if you’re motivated to try!

Secondly, the underlying purpose of this – and I strongly suspect all similar posts on TuS – is not to ‘glorify’ an achievement in Scotland relative to others: performance in treating sick people should not be viewed as any sort of competition between institutions. Poor NHS performance anywhere can have very harmful effects and in any event Scotland’s A&E waiting times performance at present is far from what most would wish it to be.

No, the point here is to make a small contribution towards countering the prevailing negativity from BBC Scotland’s news coverage. This is only needed – and the level of negativity can capable of being sustained by the broadcaster – because characteristically its coverage lacks context, lacks perspective, avoids national comparisons favouring Scotland’s NHS and Government, and is seemingly allergic to ‘good news’!

9 thoughts on “A decade’s perspective in just four graphs – A&E waiting times performance

  1. BBC Scotland Health Correspondent:
    “Ah, but, jist lookit how the Scoattish graph plummets al the end. That’s pure bad so it is! In fack that’s whit it hus aye been like. We spoke tae an ordnary hoosewife frae Dumbarton ca’d Jackie Baillie an she sez, that’s thae Essempee fur yese.”

    Liked by 5 people

  2. Some years ago, I had a letter published in the Herald to the effect that the BBC should, by its very nature, be able to educate and inform us across the UK, on health and other issues: that we can all learn from each other on best practice. A Good Thing, I naively thought.
    Alas, the BBC fails to live up to its name as BRITISH. It gives daily stats and information on England, usually with a meaningless aside about the rest of us—- when it can be bothered to report on us at all.

    BBC Scotland is the very dregs of journalism, sadly. Shallow, watered-down, opinionated and biased.
    I believe BBC Scotland is under the cosh of London, with “commissars” in place to keep them to the Party Line.
    Starved of cash and staff. No ambition at any level. An outlet for British nationalism on a state run broadcaster, with politically-connected leadership at the top.

    Increasingly no audience for their agitprop.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Gavin


      I believe BBC Scotland is under the cosh of London, with “commissars” in place to keep them to the Party Line.”

      Many of the pathetic Quay staffers aren’t under any cosh. They are self motivated British Propagandists.

      Like

  3. As Stewartb shows this info is not difficult to find – and for an organisation with a billion £ budget and numerous highly paid ”journalists” this should be readily available .
    As to WHY this organisation CHOOSES to filter info ( especially Health info ) and not properly inform the Scottish public – well , it beats me ! LoL !

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Indeed bravo Stewart, a most detailed analysis.

    Your final paragraph is a perspective with which I sincerely believe the vast majority of Scots would concur irrespective of political persuasion, the BBC in Scotland has not only failed in it’s duty to inform, but has done so deliberately.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.