I take little pleasure (;-)) in the Scottish Tories and BBC HQ getting wet today but it gives me the excuse to get my rebuttal in before the butts from yoons about Scotland’s SNP flood defences appear, like John Beattie’s exploitation of the Loch Lomond drownings.
It tweeted this 5 hours ago:
Talking-up Scotland@ProfJWR·When will opposition parties claim Scotland’s flood defences are not good enough and Sturgeon is in some way to blame? Go on. It’ll give me a chance to repeat how our stricter planning and building regs mean damage is far less here than in Rumpuk.
No sign so far.
Never mind, I have the answers in my archives:
The evidence for Scotland having better flood protection, never mentioned in our NoMedia:
As far back as 2006, researchers at the English College of Estates Management, whose patron is HRH Prince of Wales, made a number of highly encouraging comments about the achievements of the Labour-run Scottish Executive, SEPA and the Local Authorities:
As far as flood protection is concerned, unlike in England, the 1 in 200-year standard of protection is ‘universal’ for all new buildings, with a 1,000-year standard for such vulnerable uses as old people’s homes, schools, hospitals etc. In addition, construction in flood hazard areas has almost completely ended. Crichton (2003: 26) estimates that “the active flood management programme currently in progress will result in almost all high-risk properties being protected against the 200-year flood within the next three years, taking climate change into account.” It is also interesting to note that the Scottish Executive grants for flood defences have never been refused on the grounds of budget restraints and there is no rationing of flood defence spending.
It is clear, however, that the more stringent building standards which are applied in Scotland ensure that severe storms result in much less property damage than comparable events in England. Also, the level of flood protection and the commitment of funding to achieve flood protection are higher in Scotland than in England.’
College of Estates Management at: https://www.cem.ac.uk/media/28193/flooding.pdf