Sheffield goes full Scottish on testing and tracing

Retired Dr Bing Jones of Sheffield

From Richard Horsman, The Tusker‘s North of England Correspondent

As the Grampian contact tracers work on the coronavirus outbreak with a connection to a pub in Aberdeen there was a timely piece which touched on contact tracing in England on this morning’s Radio Five Breakfast ( BBC Sounds at 8.38am 3/08)    

The topics being discussed were local lock-downs and the new 90-Minute test. As the UK government seems to have delegated current responsibility and presumably blame to council level, Public Health England now publishes a full list of weekly cases and Cases per 100 000 population, by town or locality.

They are in order of worst case numbers/100k with the Top 20 being  “on a watch list“.

The 2 guests on the show were a Peterborough councillor and a retired Doctor from Sheffield. Peterborough is a new entrant to the top 20 and Sheffield is moving in the right direction ….. down the charts and off the watch list.

When asked what Sheffield had done right Dr Bing Jones of Sheffield discussed that he had set up an optional voluntary contact tracing system in the city before UK’s Test and Trace was set up.   The system he has used is very similar to that used in Scotland and Ceredigion in Wales, rather than relying on, as he put it, the national  commercial laboratories and contact tracers the UK Government has invested in.

He  described that system as divorced from the local medical services. 

Although Sheffield’s new cases are fairly high at c 100 a week he points out  that they have been chasing  down cases with pro-active testing in local labs and logically they have higher case numbers resulting.

When asked about the new 90-minute test he said that it would be nice if it actually worked like that. 

“The way we’ve managed the whole process has been a catastrophe on all sorts of levels.” 

Dr Jones listed previously broken promises on testing, PPE and the recent abandonment of care home testing in England, then asserted that the UK government gives systematic misinformation.

“All the time they are talking-up what is actually going on. They’re  saying things are better than they actually are.”

More of this please BBC Five Live!

Well observed Dr Jones.

4 thoughts on “Sheffield goes full Scottish on testing and tracing

  1. Telling it as it is? Well, he won’t get invited back.

    And certainly not to Scotland’s Radio Pravda, Home to the wondrousness of Boris, Ruthie and Wee Dougie.

    Not forgetting Carlot, who sacrificed his all, for kith kin and party— though he wasn’t told until handed the revolver outside the drawing room.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. An article in the online Guardian at the moment from clinical virologists pointing out the weaknesses in the testing system with particular reference to the private companies doing the testing via Lighthouse labs. Interesting and some of it has been highlighted by others such as the President of the Institute of Biomedical Laboratory Sciences. There is a disconnect between the Lighthouse labs and the NHS labs when it comes to reporting results and when it comes to the Quality Assurance of the results from the privatised system which a 90 min test will not address but will probably serve to highlight this issue even more.

    Liked by 3 people

  3. “Current contact and tracing performance in England is inadequate to prevent a second wave when schools re-open ”

    Heard this reported on the BBC’s radio station based in Scotland, their report gave me the impression that Scotlands test and trace system was inadequate, perhaps, as this was covered immediately after talking about Scotlands exam results.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.