
After reading in the Guardian on 29th April: ‘Third of UK Covid-19 patients taken to hospital die, study finds‘, I emailed the Chief Investigator of the research team, Professor Semple, to ask for a Scottish breakdown of the data.
He passed the request on to a Scottish member of the team who provided me with this:
At the moment in Scotland: To compare like with like, I have restricted this to patients who were admitted at least 2 weeks ago (this is a week later than the overall cohort), in order to enable most patients to finish their hospital journey. Out of 788 patients, 142 (18%) have died, 415 (53%) have been discharged alive, and 232 patients remain in hospital.
At first sight, the Scottish sample seems small given the UK sample of ‘nearly 17 000’. With 8% of the population, you might expect a sample of 1360.
However, Scotland has less cases in the first place, only 6.6%, of the UK total. 6.6% of the 17 000 is 1122 so perhaps the sample is reasonably valid.
The 18% mortality in Scottish hospitals is significantly lower than that, 33% across the UK.
It’s not entirely surprising given the higher staffing levels and better performance in infection control, with many English hospitals failing inspections on this criterion, in recent times:
I can find no example of Scottish hospital failing inspections.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Why has Ms Lisa Summers not reported on this? Is there a pigeon angle? Or is that a flight of fancy??
LikeLiked by 2 people