The slaughterhouse of journalism – hysterically politicising a staff dispute in an Aberdeen hospital with only 0.07% higher mortality – hogwash!

Fast and perceptive as you like, MSM Monitor has responded to the above stories with:

There is more to the NHS Grampian story than the BBC is reporting. This 2019 tribunal includes two of the doctors featured by BBC Scotland in recent days. Each is in opposing camps. Allegations of racism and discrimination. Are vendettas at play here? https://x.com/msm_monitor/status/2123388743860314566

I’ll take advantage of the space in a blog to elaborate a bit, hopefully helpfully.

The above two NHS Grampian medics referred to, appear in more detail in this 23 September 2019 Employment Tribunal report:

with this judgement:

When we dig into the full report, we begin to see where and how the media reports have misjudged the so-called whistle-blowing of a doctor, Mr M Habib, claiming Aberdeen Royal Infirmary is a ‘slaughterhouse’.

The consultant suggesting a ‘slaughterhouse’ in his place of work, Mr M Habib, appears 19 times in the report. Most revealing and shocking is a statement by the claimant, Professor Krukowski:

Later that morning I attended a meeting with P King, I Ahmed, W Craig and Stuart Stephen (Unit Operational Director). This patient’s death following the aborted and ill-conceived procedure carried out by M Habib and I Ahmed arose.

The report goes on to mention:

The report recorded the perceptions of Prof Ahmed, Mr Alkari and Mr Habib that there had been elements of harassment, bullying and mobbing which they suspected to be motivated by discrimination against the protected characteristics of race and faith.

What seems clear is that the media references to the hospital being a ‘slaughterhouse‘ emerge not from an objective empirical study but rather, from a horribly exaggerated and sensationalised assessment for the sole purpose of maligning a perceived critic in the internal politics of a hospital.

I am confident that the term ‘slaughterhouse’ is hysterical for this simple reason:

From the published Hospital Standardised Mortality Ratio for January 2019 to December 2019, the period referred to in the above tribunal:

These data are clear. The Aberdeen Royal Infirmary had a mortality ration only 0.02 above the NHS Scotland standard of 1.00 and around the same or less than half, of Scotland’s hospitals. Out of 43 225 patients only 32 (0.07%) more than expected died. A ‘slaughterhouse’ would require a lot mere blood.

The claim is hogwash.

Sources:

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5dc1837ced915d1d02a5a092/Krukowski_v_Grampian_Health_Board-4104651.16-Final.pdf

https://www.publichealthscotland.scot/publications/hospital-standardised-mortality-ratios/hospital-standardised-mortality-ratios-january-2019-to-december-2019/


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One thought on “The slaughterhouse of journalism – hysterically politicising a staff dispute in an Aberdeen hospital with only 0.07% higher mortality – hogwash!”

  1. All part of a campaign to drip feed to Scots that we are not fit to run out own affairs. Expect a full onslaught before council elections next year. Liebour will throw everything behind getting that SEMMP baad out in Glasgow. Aided and abetted by the Oninonist press.

    Like

Leave a Reply