
Read evidence at: https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=pay+for
From the Scottish Government today at 3.45pm, 90 mins ago, but no mention on BBC Scotland website. Increased drug deaths typically takes them 15 mins to get up:

The Deputy First Minister also confirmed that the Scottish Government will ensure that households in Scotland benefit from the £100 payment for energy bills support.
Jenny Gilruth said that while any measures to bring down the cost of energy bills are welcome, the steps confirmed by the Chancellor today fall far short of what is required and do not meet the promises on which the UK Government came to office.
The Deputy First Minister said:
“The Scottish Government’s budget will be cut by around £650 million next year – reducing the money we have to spend on public services and supporting people with the cost of living.
Full text at: https://www.gov.scot/news/uk-budget-delivers-real-cut-to-scotlands-funding/
More evidence of other England-only costs we’ll pay for because Barnett Consequentials compensation will be too much bother to implement and, anyway, can be wiped out by just unilaterally reducing the block grant:

Read evidence at: https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=pay+for
These are only a few. Try: https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=Barnett
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

“… the Scottish Government will ensure that households in Scotland benefit from the £100 payment for energy bills support.”
OK but SURELY the Scottish Government will take the opportunity to point out that many, perhaps most, Council Tax payers in Scotland – based on national and regional range and average payment statistics – will probably already pay over £100 per annum LESS than comparable CT payers in England. And many, perhaps. most, households in Scotland are also likely to pay substantially less on water and sewerage charges than in England.
Anyone inclined to spend time confirming the above with hard facts might be interested in this source – https://counciltaxcalc.co.uk . I doubt it will occur to the public service broadcaster or other MSM journalists to ponder the relative significance for household budgets of a selective £100 reduction in CT bills in Scotland compared to England.
On both CT and water bills, households in Scotland are benefiting from the management of public finances by a government in Edinburgh that is – let’s not forget – severely constrained or devoid of fiscal, monetary, borrowing, economic, trade and labour market etc. powers relative to England’s government in Westminster where all these powers are held in full by what is a currency-issuing government.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Day after day it becomes more and more evident that The King of the North has zero interest in Scotland but , like his predecessors , cannot allow Scotland to acquire Independence as this would , inevitably , bankrupt England !
LikeLiked by 1 person
Long comment, so apologies , but it seems that this particular news is of absolutely no interest to the vast majority of the media who supposedly report the “news where we are” within Scotland
Prof. Robertson you wrote “From the Scottish Government today at 3.45pm, 90 mins ago, but no mention on BBC Scotland website”.
It’s the “but no mention on BBC Scotland website” that caught my eye.
That’s because there is (yet) another (political) story , which has been ongoing since September, that the BBC in Scotland has chosen not to mention.
(Neither has many of the other media within Scotland noted this (political) story – is it Omertà , Wheesht for Labour or the media in Scotland circling the wagons in them trying to protect one of their own).
Yesterday I noted that on social media there was a story about Paul Hutcheon and Joani Reid that was sourced from The Glasgow Bell via The Private Eye.
The Bell posted this :
“Exclusive: The Bell has learned political editor of the Daily Record, Paul Hutcheon, has quit, after an alleged affair with Labour MP for East Kilbride, Joani Reid. As reported by Private Eye, Hutcheon oversaw favourable exclusives of Reid at his paper in past few months”.
However this story first emerged last month in The Scottish Sun , who at the time did not name the male (Hutcheon) but instead made an ambiguous description of a “married man who is well known in the Scottish parliament”.
So why was The Sun, a rival newspaper of the Daily record, protecting Hutcheon ?
Why were they, The Scottish Sun, so coy in not mentioning that a married political editor of a Scottish newspaper was exposed as being someone that was having an affair with a Labour MP who , as an MP, had already been in the media via another scandal(s) ? (Indeed she , Reid, was suspended and then she was reinstated as a Labour MP by Andy Burnham as the new Labour PM).
Hutcheon was a political Editor of a Scottish newspaper who often posted on ‘X’ in respect to Reid and was noted as having written “favourable exclusives of Reid” .
Reid was also someone who was noted and quoted in various Daily Record pieces.
Not forgetting also that Paul Hutcheon was also someone who was often on BBC’s Politics Scotland as a journalist who was then allowed to opine on various sessions of FM Q’s , aka one who was referred to by the Scottish Sun as being “”married man who is well known in the Scottish parliament”.
Now before anyone states or thinks that this is a private ‘affair’ then please note Paul Hutcheon was a political Editor of a Scottish newspaper that was distributed in Scotland and Joani Reid is a Labour MP elected in Scotland in 2024.
Also note that both Hutcheon and Reid often sought to criticise and so attack the SNP , as does The ‘Scottish’ Sun and The Daily Record.
So basically we are very much within the territory of those who assume and so then expect a high moral standard to be applied and so then adopted by all SNP politicians, while this same rule does not apparently apply to them , as a pro UK politician, a pro UK Journalist or a pro UK newspaper.
Today there is , so far, a news blackout on this shocking revelation that The Private Eye first revealed in September 2026 based on a story by the Scottish Sun also published in September 2026, where much of the detail (including the blurred image of Mr Hutcheon) was omitted.
Since September Hutcheon had not posted anything for a month on ‘X’.
(He is now back posting on ‘X’ as if nothing has happened, though he no longer has a reference to him being the Political Editor at The Daily Record in his bio profile on ‘X’)
I also noted that Joani Reid posted this on September:
“There is a huge contrast between Labour’s Andy Burnham and the programme for change and renewal he articulated today and the SNP’s recipe for stagnation recently presented at Holyrood. John Swinney just isn’t in the same class when it comes to leadership”.
Reid talking about ‘class’ in reference to another politician, gallus indeed.
Do I need to mention that had this been a SNP politician , as in one who had already been noted as being involved in another scandal(s) , then there surely would have been a ongoing wall to wall coverage on this . (including demands for that SNP politician to resign).
One does wonder whether the Labour party ( as in Burnham) were perhaps a tad too hasty in reinstating Ms Reid , though the media are doing their best to back up Labour’s decision in their trying to hush this new (latest) scandal up.
However is this now just going to be continued to be ignored by the various media sources within Scotland and elsewhere as if it is not a reality as a scandal ?
Well so far it seems that is indeed the case.
If so then let us never allow nor accept any of the media here in Scotland to assume that they have the right to critique or pass judgement upon any SNP MP’s, the current or past SNP FM’s, Scottish SNP MSP’s and also Scottish government Ministers for their behaviour or supposed mistakes , as it seems that they, as a media in Scotland, are very selective in what they want to promote as being a scandal in them choosing to not critique nor pass judgement on a story that is clearly #LabourMPBad in content. (same goes for politicians like Joani Reid who often attacks and criticises the SNP and who also often attacks and criticises both the current FM and also former SNP FM’s).
This media omission on this story is clearly driven by both political bias so is very much partisan in nature. However it also the media in Scotland seeking to protect one of their own , as in one (Hutcheon) who posted this on ‘X’ on 5 May 2026:
“The Daily Record urges Scots to vote for change after 19 years of SNP Government. “We can keep Reform out and send a message to the hopeless SNP that Scots deserve a better, brighter future.”.
Well thank God a lot of the people of Scotland ignored The Daily Record and Paul Hutcheon as instead we chose to vote for the SNP which then sent “a message” to The Daily Record and also to the Labour party that then prevented the ‘hopeless” Labour party from winning the Scottish election in May 2026 .
Many Scots obviously decided that yes we did “deserve a better, brighter future” which we many of us knew we will only get if we keep voting for the SNP and then eventually we , via majority, vote for independence.
The Private Eye piece upon Hutcheon and Reid is entitled as “Tawdry in Tartan” and is based upon The Scottish Sun piece on 5 September 2026.
(What luck that today the Budget of the UK Chancellor should dominate all of the news where we are and also news elsewhere too, as in no space or time for mentioning or highlighting scandals in the news today – or rather it seems, no need to mention or highlight a certain scandal on any day, especially a scandal linked to a certain Labour politician representing a certain constituency within a certain nation within the UK State ).
Liz S
LikeLiked by 1 person
Note in my comment above, these are currently allegations of an alleged “affair” between Hutcheon and Reid, something one must highlight, but surely if they were indeed false as allegations , then the two people noted in this story would have refuted the allegation as being false, as both of their respective reputations would have been or should have been badly damaged by this revelation , as in this revelation of an alleged affair between them.
Liz S
LikeLike
The Private Eye piece upon Hutcheon and Reid is entitled as “Tawdry in Tartan” and is based upon The Scottish Sun piece on 5 September 2026.
Note upon checking this page it is now no longer to be found on this piece in The Private Eye magazine. This is getting quite strange is it not.
As in wtf is really going on here.
Note to Prof Robertson – my above comment is one that you should most certainly not promote as a TUS post , as there is something most most whiffy about this story.
A story that I assumed was a conflict of interest , being that one of the people allegedly involved was a political editor of a newspaper in Scotland that favoured the Labour party.
Liz S
LikeLike
* which we many of us knew we will only get if we keep voting for the SNP and then eventually we , via majority, vote for independence.
which many of us knew that we would only get if we keep voting for the SNP and then eventually we , via majority, vote for independence.
Liz S
LikeLiked by 1 person
Only last year, the UK Labour Government committed to provide the Acorn Carbon Capture and Storage project in NE Scotland with a grant of £200m to assist with its onward development. Yesterday’s budget renegaded on that commitment, replacing it with a reference to potential future financial support from government via ill-defined loan or equity support. The Secretary of State for Scotland then made – again vague – comments in public which imply weaknesses in the Acorn project.
As far as I can see, the UK’s other CCUS project in a similar stage of development – namely Viking, located in the Humber region – will continue to receive grant support.
Is this a consequence of the de-industrialisation of Scotland – loss of the Grangemouth refinery and the Mossmorran chemical plant? Douglas Alexander would be loath to have to admit that such de-industrialistion is reducing the demand for carbon capture in Scotland unlike in Teeside, NW England and the Humber?
And with uncertainty over Acorn increased further yesterday, what impact on the proposed new gas-fired power station in Peterhead which was planned to accompany a CCS facility? More of Jackdaw gas available to be sent south to power England, along with all that electricity from offshore wind farms?
But don’t fret, Scotland can look forward to new nuclear power plants courtesy of Westminster!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Talking of new nuclear power plants … Even avid readers of the BBC News website are likely to have missed the following news item of significant UK-wide relevance that was published on Budget day. It’s yet another example of ‘puzzling’ BBC editorial decisions in its online news reporting.
From the BBC News website (October 28) this headline: ‘Sizewell C terrible deal for taxpayers, say MPs’ (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cw0k0128dx55o#comments)
The BBC report has this: ‘‘A report published by the House of Commons’ Public Accounts Committee (PAC) said Sizewell C, near Leiston, was “high risk” and it would be the taxpayer who would foot the majority of the bill if there were delays. The project is expected to cost between £40.5bn and £47.7bn, with construction finishing between 2039 and 2043.’
Conservative MP Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, chair of the PAC, is reported as saying: “.. high level of risk borne by taxpayers and consumers” was “extraordinary”. “Private investors look set for significant returns on their investments, while customers are likely to be saddled with higher energy bills”.
This coverage of the PAC report on Sizewell appeared in the BBC New website’s England Local News section for Suffolk – and nowhere else, as far as I can see!
This limited, local profile is despite the rationale for the Sizewell project being based on UK-wide energy supply and security issues, not just Suffolk-wide; the public funding of the project being from UK sources (obviously), not just Suffolk ones; and the risks from this project affecting taxpayers and consumers UK-wide, not just Suffolk-wide! Also the authors of this critical report are cross-party MPs elected from across the UK, not just from Suffolk! So why does the BBC tuck it out of sight?
Some notable quotes from the Summary of the PAC’s report to make good the information that the BBC did not share with taxpayers and voters in Scotland who, let’s not forget, are being encouraged by Unionist politicians to embrace new nuclear power generation:
The very first line: ‘Sizewell C represents a terrible deal for the UK taxpayer.’ – and one could argue therefore an EVEN worse deal, if that’s possible, for taxpayers in Scotland as a part of the UK with no need of Sizewell C!
Also from the PAC report: ‘Sizewell C is a high-risk mega project. No comparable nuclear power station anywhere in the world has been built on time and to budget. Sizewell C is expected to cost between £40.5 billion and £47.7 billion and is expected to finish construction between 2039 and 2043. ….. The design has a poor international delivery record, with a clear pattern of delays and cost escalations.’
The PAC report notes: ‘The Department’s novel approach to building Sizewell C means it holds a minority shareholding, but the government and consumers provide most of the money and bear most of the risk. This leaves the delivery body on the government’s balance sheet but not in the Department’s control.’
‘If construction costs rise from £40.5 billion to £47.7 billion, consumers would pay £9.8 billion more during Sizewell C’s construction and a further £12 billion over its 60-year operating life in order to cover the additional payments to debt providers and shareholders as well as the additional construction cost (all in real terms). By contrast, the funding model means private investors would only need to contribute an additional £30 million in cash. In addition to taxpayer equity and debt financing, government has provided a series of guarantees, at least one of which has a maximum value of £70 billion (nominal).’
And the PAC cautions: ‘There is a historical trend of nuclear power station decommissioning taking longer and costing more than expected, with these additional costs being picked up by the UK taxpayer. …… Sizewell C Ltd will set aside money over the course of its operational lifetime to cover its decommissioning, funded by consumers. Sizewell C is expected to invest between £5.1 billion and £5.8 billion nominal into this fund (£2.3 billion and £2.5 billion in 2024–25 real terms) with the rest of the estimated £12 billion (2022 real terms) of decommissioning costs coming from the accumulation of the invested funds. The Committee nevertheless remains concerned that history will repeat itself.’
But no mention by the PAC of the very long term legacy impact of toxic nuclear waste from the plant! What was that about ‘not burdening future generations’ trotted out by certain political parties in the UK?
The time span to Sizewell C coming online – to 2039-2043 at least. Should be more than enough time to develop alternatives for Scotland – to ensure the electricity grid in Scotland is capable of exploiting optimally the power generated from on and offshore Scotland’s wind; more than enough time to bring more offshore wind farms online; more than enough time to bring tidal power plants to commercial scale; enough time to complete additional pump storage hydro facilities; more than enough time to ensure sufficient battery storage and to invest in energy saving initiatives and to invest in local energy generation schemes across Scotland. And then there might also be hydrogen to consider?
LikeLike