Just a few of those interviewed by Scottish media to attack SNP or Scottish Government who are then revealed to be opposition party activists or candidates

Toni Dawson, Largs shop-owner, interviewed by STV after flood damage just the latests of thes.

  • Professor June Andrews (multiple appearances, 2024–2026): A dementia specialist and former nurse (often billed by expertise and OBE) appeared on BBC Radio Scotland’s Good Morning Scotland supporting means-testing of the Winter Fuel Payment (comments later used to challenge an SNP minister) and on Scotcast in an NHS debate. She was a Scottish Labour activist who campaigned for Labour candidates and stood (unsuccessfully) as a Labour candidate in a 2025 West Lothian local by-election. The BBC issued corrections in both cases, acknowledging the political links should have been flagged when discussion touched on political decisions.⁠
  • Lord Willie Haughey: On a June 2025 Debate Night “Glasgow Special” (eve of the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election), he was described as an entrepreneur and Labour donor. He is a Labour peer (and significant past donor). The BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit ruled this a breach of accuracy standards; a correction was issued. The panel also included another Labour MSP.⁠
  • Robert Kilgour: Interviewed on BBC Scotland about the Scottish Government’s National Care Service plans. He is a significant Conservative donor (tens of thousands of pounds recorded by the Electoral Commission) and founder/chairman of the pro-Union group Scottish Business UK. The BBC later issued a correction stating it “would have been better” to reference these links given the political context of his comments.⁠
  • Professor Richard Kerley (2023): Appeared on BBC Scotland as a local-government expert discussing facility closures by a Labour-run council. He had been a Labour councillor in the 1980s and a 1983 parliamentary candidate. A viewer complaint was dismissed by the BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit on the grounds that the affiliation was ~40 years old and he is primarily known as an expert.⁠
  • Sam Taylor (These Islands): Frequently appears in Scottish and UK media as head of a pro-Union think tank criticising SNP energy claims, fiscal figures, and other policies. In 2026 he was photographed campaigning for Scottish Labour (including with Anas Sarwar) and admitted he is a party member who campaigns in a personal capacity. These Islands is not formally party-affiliated, but the personal link was not always prominent in coverage.⁠
  • Ayesha Hazarika: A frequent BBC Scotland and other commentator (former special adviser to senior Labour figures, later made a Labour peer). On one Sunday Show appearance she referred to Labour as “they”; another guest publicly noted the discrepancy with her close ties.

Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

3 thoughts on “Just a few of those interviewed by Scottish media to attack SNP or Scottish Government who are then revealed to be opposition party activists or candidates”

  1. Whoever this woman is, may I remind her that King Canute is often misrepresented in children’s stories. The historical lesson is that human beings cannot control the forces of nature simply by wishing them to. The same principle applies here: humans do not control the climate or the natural forces that shape it.

    Like

  2. The BBC’s Debate Night on tonight has yet another mostly hostile SNP panel.

    Michael Shanks – Malcolm Offord – Roz Foyer – and unbelievably, yet for the BBC, not so unbelievable , also on the panel is Ralph Roberts the Chairman of McGill’s (Buses).

    There is also one SNP MSP and that is David Linden.

    I would be shocked if there was not also a hostile audience in this episode which this week is in Airdrie.

    Then of course the host himself is not exactly neutral is he , so he too as a BBC employee, can also be regarded as hostile (more so if you ever listen to any BBC GMS Radio programmes and some of the topics covered on there when he, Jardine, hosts it ).

    I am sure the majority, if not all, of the Q’s asked by audience members tonight on BBC Debate Night will all be topics framed as #SNPBAD , as will the answers be from much of the hostile panel.

    Though really the obvious Q’s that should be asked of all the hostile #SNPBAD panel guests will no doubt be the ones that this programme will not select as Q’s to be asked .

    After all this BBC Scotland programme, just like BBC QT whenever it is in Scotland, has an obvious agenda that must be adhered to, in that every episode must stick to the agenda which is always #SNPBAD.

    Liz S

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply