Above, the young man in the Daily Mail‘s:
Local resident doubts Sturgeon’s claim she knew nothing about campervan bought with embezzled funds
because he met her, he did, he said so, four years ago, when he was presumably 14.
According to his own blog
My name is Ryan-Thomas Quinn, I am 18, a journalism student, activist and avid enjoyer of wine (preferably rosé). My views are mine and mine alone however, I work regularly with and have friends across the political spectrum. Collaboration is key!
Across the political spectrum?
In Scottish media reports of SNP or Scottish Government failures have there been cases where witnesses described as ‘just members of the public’ have on examination turned out to opposition party or Unionist activists with an agenda?
Yes, there have been documented cases, particularly involving BBC Question Time (and similar audience/vox pop formats) in Scotland. https://www.thenational.scot/news/20248698.bbc-question-time-inverness-audience-member-outed-tory-activist/
thenational.scotScottish pro-independence outlets (e.g., The National) and SNP figures have repeatedly highlighted instances where audience members or “ordinary public” voices criticizing the SNP/Scottish Government were later identified as opposition activists, often Conservatives/Unionists. Mainstream outlets sometimes present these as neutral public sentiment. This fits a broader narrative of perceived media bias in Scottish politics, where Unionist-leaning coverage is accused of amplifying anti-SNP voices without full disclosure. https://www.thecanary.co/uk/news/2019/05/20/snp-deputy-blasts-bbc-question-time-for-audience-stuffed-full-of-tory-plants/
Examples
- BBC Question Time in Inverness (2022): An audience member who criticized the SNP was outed as a Conservative campaigner/activist. This drew accusations that the BBC had not properly vetted or disclosed affiliations, presenting them as a neutral “member of the public.” thenational.scot
- Other Question Time episodes: SNP deputy leader Keith Brown and others criticized the show for audiences “stuffed full of Tory plants.” Specific cases included Unionist activists or former candidates featured prominently in anti-SNP segments. One incident involved secret editing of an SNP response to a question from a “Unionist plant.” https://www.thenational.scot/news/17430795.revealed-question-time-secretly-edited-snp-answer-unionist-plant/
- Broader pattern with vox pops and debates: Critics (including on social media and pro-SNP forums) point to BBC Scotland and other outlets relying heavily on street interviews or audience questions that disproportionately feature vocal SNP opponents. These are framed as representative “public” opinion, but examination sometimes reveals party links. Studies and commentary note broadcasters’ heavy use of vox pops in Scottish/UK election coverage, which can amplify unrepresentative or activist voices without rigorous checking. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/may/20/broadcasters-reliant-vox-pop-interviews-failing-challenge-politicians-study
These incidents are more common in TV/radio formats.
Perhaps the best/worst was Billy Mitchell (often called “Orange Jacket Man”), a vocal Unionist who appeared multiple times on BBC Question Time. https://www.thenational.scot/news/17447021.question-times-angry-unionist-threatens-blow-lid-bbc/
Key Details
- Repeated appearances: He featured at least 3–4 times (reports vary on the exact count, with some claiming more), including notable spots in 2013 (Stirling) and prominently in 2019 (Motherwell episode). He stood out due to his distinctive orange jacket and strong anti-SNP tirades.https://www.scotsman.com/regions/bbc-question-time-criticised-after-three-time-audience-member-slams-snp-126515
- Background: Former UKIP council candidate (Coatbridge area). He was linked to loyalist flute bands (e.g., Livingston area) and widely described in pro-independence media and commentary as having Orange Order connections or sympathies. Mitchell denied being a formal Orange Order member or flute band participant when questioned, calling such claims smears, but critics highlighted his Unionist activism, social media, and associations. https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/3853746/bbc-under-fire-failed-billy-mitchell-scots-ukip-question-time/
- Controversy: His repeat appearances sparked accusations of BBC bias — presenting him as an ordinary “member of the public” while he was a known activist. This fueled claims that the show (and BBC Scotland) favored critical Unionist voices against the SNP. The BBC said it was investigating audience selection processes at the time. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/bbc-question-time-investigating-after-13971180
This case became a prominent example in debates about Scottish media impartiality around 2019, often cited alongside other audience “plants” controversies on Question Time and similar shows.
Discover more from Talking-up Scotland
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Talking-up Scotland 