Why Labour’s plans for nuclear in Scotland are both stupid and risk the lives of children and mature women

BBC Reporting Scotland last night offered a one-sided piece on nuclear power restarting in Scotland and, in particular – the new small modular reactors or SMRs.

The piece opened and was dominated by, supporters of the idea with a token Scottish Government comment at the end but none of the real concerns.

The stupid first, then the horrific risks Labour will accept on your behalf just in the hope of winning votes. All of these comments can be backed up by hard evidence at:

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=SMR

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=gas

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=electricity

https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/?s=cancer

The stupid:

We produce four times the natural gas we consume and transfer huge amounts of electricity to the rest of the UK – we don’t need nuclear.

There are only two SMRs running in Russia and China – not tried and tested.

US companies are abandoning plans for them – too costly, too unreliable.

The risks:

They are less likely to meltdown but are more leaky producing more waste.

They rely on a richer blend of uranium to run and Russia has a near monopoly on that.

The waste takes thousands of years to become safe.

The security risks from terrorists and organised crime are already high with just a few big ones to protect. You’d need many of these small ones and so much difficult to protect.

There are proven higher risks of childhood leukaemia and breast cancer among mature women, especially, for those living near nuclear sites and Scotland already has the highest cancer rates in Europe.

All claims backed up by peer-reviewed research at the above links.

5 thoughts on “Why Labour’s plans for nuclear in Scotland are both stupid and risk the lives of children and mature women

  1. Labour will be voted out. Get rid of Trident.

    Scotland losing £Billions because of Brexit. Redundant weaponry, HS2, Hinkley Point etc.

    Like

  2. SMRs are ‘safe’ because they won’t be built anywhere near a Labour MP’s home !

    SMRs are economical because nuclear donors to the Labour Party have said so !

    SMRs are needed because Scotland’s Renewables are not producing profit for the Nuclear Industry !

    Like

  3. Aye, it is amazing how often BBC Scotland has platformed this crap over an as yet unproven nuclear design to viewers hundreds of miles away from where leccy is in short supply, and where ideal soils for storing the nuclear waste underground persist….

    As if we don’t have enough of London’s nuclear junk berthed in Rosyth etc…

    Like

  4. Fired off another complaint to these nakedly obvious Slab campaigning broadcasters. Beyond disgusting.

    p.s. I’m the same age as you John but I’m extremely handsome and will gets loads of Valentines next month….. (I wish).

    Like

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.