Daily Record columnist, Annie Brown, provides Monica Lennon and Scottish Labour with yet another set of misinterpreted evidence which they can use to return to their long-disproved thesis that the Scottish Government is responsible for the care home deaths.
It’s a new low in journalism, biased from the outset and ironically ‘cherry picking’ of evidence.
First, she writes:
In the first wave of the pandemic, more than 1,300 elderly people were discharged from hospitals to care homes in Scotland before a testing regime was in place. The government said a Public Health Scotland report “did not find statistical evidence that hospital discharges of any kind were associated with care home outbreaks”. This is skilful cherry picking of a report which actually could be interpreted to say quite the opposite. Another such report is out today, so let’s see what acrobatics of interpretation the government can perform this time.
All untrue, demonstrably, from several reports:
After the first wave, the charitable MHA with a presence in Scotland did research into its own homes and discovered this: Large numbers of staff could have been unknowingly spreading coronavirus through care homes, according to the UK’s largest charitable care home provider. Data from MHA shows 42% of its staff members who recently tested positive were not displaying symptoms. Nearly 45% of residents who had a positive test were also asymptomatic. The MHA Chief Executive said: I think it’s very difficult not to see that the only real way that this can have come into our homes is through staff picking it up, just through the community contacts they would have had. I think that is what is so hard for all our staff, because they care. But if they don’t know they’ve contracted the virus, how can you manage this?https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-52912538
Then a large ONS study of 9 081 care homes in England found this: These emerging findings reveal some common factors in care homes with higher levels of infections amongst residents.These include prevalence of infection in staff, some care home practices such as more frequent use of bank or agency nurses or carers, and some regional differences (such as higher infection levels within care homes in London and the West Midlands). There is some evidence that in care homes where staff receive sick pay, there are lower levels of infection in residents. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/conditionsanddiseases/articles/impactofcoronavirusincarehomesinenglandvivaldi/26mayto19june2020#main-points
Pay attention: There is no evidence that hospital discharges caused outbreaks in care homes.
Then, with the arrogance of Sarwar, she writes
Nicola Sturgeon said, with the benefit of hindsight, “mistakes” were made with care home residents at the start of the crisis. Forget hindsight 20 /20 since the impact of this move, could have been predicted with no more knowledge than gleaned watching the movie Contagion. Deadly viruses introduced to vulnerable people in confined spaces, kill them, here endeth the medical lesson.
Astonishing contempt from a mere journo for highly trained professionals.
The decisions to discharge from hospital into care homes were taken, in the interests of the patients, many of them traumatised there by dementia, by highly qualified medics in consultation with care home managers, skilled in the isolation of infected residents from decades of flu epidemics. ‘Those in power’, SNP politicians, played no part.
The decisions of those owners in the larger corporate homes to maximise occupancy and to skimp on staffing, PPE and testing, with over-dependency on agency staff travelling between sites, caused the deaths.
Finally and disgracefully, this:
The belated remorse of the Scottish government is the equivalent of a General apologising he ordered hand grenades be thrown into care homes then feigning shock when people died. The actions of our government in 2020 were a fag paper away from euthanasia and there should have been grovelling apologies long before now. If it wasn’t for journalists we wouldn’t know the half of it.
Like the GMB and Richard Leonard before them, Lennon and Brown side with the rapacious corporations in a desperate attempt to harm the SNP.