Care home vaccination and death: bias by omission works

As BBC Scotland fussed over single cases with parents presented as the experts in how a vaccination programme should be run, a major scandal in English care homes was ignored. We now know that the death rate in these homes is twice as high as in Scottish care homes due to the UK Government’s failure to vaccinate care home residents first and before all other groups. Thousands have died unnecessarily.

3 700 UNNECESSARY CARE HOME DEATHS IN ENGLAND BECAUSE…? https://talkingupscotlandtwo.com/2021/03/03/3-700-unnecessary-care-home-deaths-in-england-because/

The only real attention to the Scottish Government’s success in this prioritising has come in First Minister’s briefings where following the JCVI advice has been offered as an explanation for the lower overall percentage vaccinated in Scotland in the first few weeks.

The Ipsos MORI poll on 25-26 February with 923 Scots, the first with a No lead (1%) for almost a year, contains within its depths evidence of an awareness that the UK Government has been successful in overall rollout, a lack of awareness of the care home deaths, of differences in vaccination strategy between the two governments and perhaps more than the Alex Salmond controversy, the suggestion of a contributory factor in any fall in support for independence.

I was shocked by one particular set of data but first on this question:

Overall, how well or badly do you think each of the following have handled the coronavirus outbreak so far?

we get 30% thinking the UK Government has done ‘well’ and 54% thinking ‘badly’ while for the Scottish Government, it’s 67% ‘well’ and 18% ‘badly.’

So far, so predictable? Professors Sridhar, Bauld and others have been on TV often enough to get that general message across.

And on the question:

Do you think the UK [or Scottish] Government has done a good job or bad job at – Making sure different groups of the population are vaccinated as soon as possible?

we get 75% to 17% feeling the UK Government has done a good job and 78% to 18% feeling the Scottish Government has done a good job.

Perhaps on a positive note, this suggests that Boris Johnson’s attempts to claim the vaccine success for the UK and suggest it is a gift to Scotland, have not had much impact, but on this question:

Do you think the UK [or Scottish] Government has done a good job or bad job at – Making sure different groups of the population are vaccinated in the right order?

we get 72% to 19% feeling the UK Government has done a good job and 78% to 18% feeling the Scottish Government has done a good job.

With twice the death rate in English care homes and a clear decision not to follow expert advice, the UK Government, clearly and objectively did a very bad job on ‘Making sure different groups of the population are vaccinated in the right order‘ yet 72% of Scots feel they did well.

Even among SNP voters, 68% agreed.

I’m often highly skeptical about negative media effects and seriously doubt the much-discussed rumours of damage to the SNP from the recent blanket coverage of the Alex Salmond case, but if voters are not told of UK Government failures, then that seems to be quite effective in protecting it.

3 thoughts on “Care home vaccination and death: bias by omission works

  1. The media are obviously not reporting the EngGov neglect of folks in the care homes in England. I follow a science blog by someone in England, who says the vaccination in the UK has been a resounding success with over 90% of over 65 year olds having had the jag. Mostly hearing cheers about it all from people in England.
    The science advice being to vaccinate those in care homes first, the English government have utterly ignored that, it’s absolutely criminal. Whether true I don’t know, but I heard someone mention a Tory MP had bragged about saving money on payments for the state pensions, due to Covid. I wouldn’t be surprised in the least.
    Looks like more people in Scotland need to spend more time reading this blog, or remain ignorant about crucial information.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. I really depresses me that we are subjected to such relentless bias and propaganda from the MS and our national broadcaster. As you say bias by omission too,

    I can’t help thinking that if we had had balanced reporting on political matters in Scotland support for indy would be 70% at least.

    Note that I say “balanced reporting”. If the media had ben biased to the same extent in favour of indy would anyone other than the most rabid right wingers still support the Union?

    Perhaps 10 to 15%? That’s how bad I think this is. By listening to the arguments from the grass root support for the Union it’s clear that it’s more or less all based on what they are hearing from the media.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Carers are now getting vaccinated to protect their loved ones. They will be able to engage and interact in safety. The vulnerable will be given more care and the vaccine.

    In Scotland carers revenues have been increased. Kinship payments keep children out of foster care. Within the family. More cost affected. Paper work has been decreased for application. People in care receive additional allowances. More educational support. No council tax burden. Other support and help packages.

    The lies and propaganda are not working. Support for SNP/Independence are increasing. Without D’Hond’t Scotland would be Independent. Less opposition. Imposed on Scotland without a mandate.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.