
On a day when the number of coronavirus deaths fell, for the fourth day consecutively and when cases also fell dramatically, Reporting Scotland went for a genre you might label ‘Gothic’ or ‘Scottish Miserabilism.’
They also, heroically, managed not to mention Dr MacAskill of Care Scotland who had announced than UK suppliers of PPE were ‘prioritising’ English care homes over Scottish ones as ‘their need was greater!’
This was despite Radio Scotland, Radio 4 News and BBC 1 News reporting it.
They certainly didn’t consider the possibility strongly suggested by the Radio 4 report that Dominic Raab was responsible for bullying the suppliers and coming up with that classic English Tory justification.
What they did have was the cadaverously handsome David Henderson with the above line, ‘Amid the light there is darkness’. Was his dad a stern Calvinist minister in the Kirk?
But first, we heard that the total of deaths is now ‘almost 600!’ It’s 575.
Then came David and he drew us in before hitting us:
‘The skys are clear. Winter’s now a memory but one thing hasn’t changed. A lock-down’s still in place. Around the country the fight against coronavirus is taking on a pattern. It’s a queue for the supermarket. An empty street. A walk in the park, at a safe distance from others but amid the light there’s darkness. 6 000 Scots are confirmed to have had the virus and almost 600 [sic] of them have now died. The true figure we’re told will be much higher and as those numbers rise, there’s a grim message from the country’s most senior health official. Don’t delay funerals…‘
I’m sorry, I can’t take any more. I know we don’t want folk getting too optimistic and rushing into each other’s arms, as they do, but was this necessary?
There’s more with deaths in a care home but he does lighten the mood a little with the comedic image of a wifie in Buckhaven arrested for hosting a pool party! Buckhaven in April! It’s a wonder they’re not all deid! Oh they are all deid! She’s charged with culpable homicide?’
That line is ridiculous. What light? The falling cases and deaths? You didn’t mention them?
6 000 infected, yes but less than 600 dead. Do you think our hospitals did well to keep the number down? Is that worse than last year from other causes? Tell us. You’re the news.
Almost 600? That’s twice. Why do that? Why not say ‘Five hundred and seventy-five?’ Not scary enough?
As for the ‘true figure’, hasn’t BBC Scotland already described the new Scottish statistics, now including deaths out of hospitals, unlike those elsewhere in UK, as just that?
Overall, this was heavy on melodrama and light on information.

Talking about numbers of deaths (in keeping with the misrerabilist tone of Mr Henderson) the BBC UK page has an article about English care homes, apparently 2099 have had Covid-19 cases. The figure of 1000 deaths in care-homes is also mentioned which doesn’t seem to ring true.
I suspect that the public are being gently introduced to the real death figures in care-homes which is likely to be horrific.
New figures will be released at 0930 which will include “every community death linked to Covid-19 in England and Wales”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Link?
LikeLike
John, this is the link to today’s ONS release, including data on ‘place of occurrence’:
https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/deaths/bulletins/deathsregisteredweeklyinenglandandwalesprovisional/weekending3april2020
See Figure 6a and associated spreadsheet.
LikeLiked by 1 person
How the BBC in Scotland hungers for blood and bad news stories , I swear you have to be a certain type to work for them , vampire perhaps ! .
LikeLiked by 1 person
Seems also to ignore that testing rate per head in Scotland 20-30% higher then England, so perhaps higher level of known infections.
Likewise we have no detail on the ‘recovered’ totals (from ICU-level treatment) which IMO should be proving equally impressive
LikeLike
This link
https://www.travellingtabby.com/scotland-coronavirus-tracker/
Gives a very similar shaped graph for total deaths in Scotland ( to 5th April) when compared with the ONS link above for England and Wales . Total deaths seem ‘about’ the same per head if you take Scotland as 10% of England/wales population?
LikeLike
Donald, he gives numbers for Scotland in the UK – popn 8.2% share, deaths about 5.5% share – that not about the same…
LikeLike
Ok that’s great thanks! That’ll teach me not to do lazy maths!
LikeLike
Nothing worse than ’rounding errors’! 🙂
LikeLike
In fact the latest is better (for Scotland) than those old figures:
Share of Population
8.2%
Share of Tests
10.9%
Share of Infections
6.8%
Share of Deaths
5.1%
LikeLike