
This survey has some pretty obvious limitations to its validity but, nevertheless, does offer some evidence that just over 5% of the followers of TuSC have switched to Yes from having been No voters or undecided in 2014, not necessarily because of TuSC. A 5% swing would, of course be enough to reverse the 52 to 48 loss in 2014 to a narrow win of the kind we’ve seen in recent polls.
In sharp contrast, only 0.4% seem to have swung from Yes to No or undecided.
On Twitter, TuSC has 3 888 followers and the post today, trying to answer the question in the headline above, was shared by 124 of them to a wider audience generating more than 7 500 impressions.
This is a self-selecting sample of the followers of a pro-independence blog with all the problems of validity and reliability that brings.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

On at least two occasions very recently, in conversations with pro-indy folk who were planning to be more active in writing letters to their local papers, I advised them that ‘Talking Up Scotland’ was a good place to find ideas for letter content. So there are other ways in which your efforts John may get amplified.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks. Increasingly ‘our’ efforts.
LikeLike
i have been sharing some of your articles on facebook-good to have chapter and verse rational counter to the drivel pumped out by msm-some undecided will read these posts, so i suspect the effect is more widespread than apparent-please keep it up!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree with stewartb, it’s not necessarily the direct contact here with people that might need persuaded – how do you get them to seek out a blog when there are so many online news sources, and mainstream claiming everyone but them is untrustworthy (!), and people aren’t aware of the need – that makes people change their minds on independence, but this blog gives others the resources, and a place to guide people, who are open to reading alternative views and context on news items, to.
It’s an impossible question to test really. But because you don’t preach, I don’t think you can be preaching to the converted – supporting them maybe? Definitely helping to persuade.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Prof., you forgot people like me who did not have a vote last time. I am now YES.
LikeLiked by 1 person
As above I share your articles . . . . . And agree with Dr. J. M. . . . the effect of your blog is more extensive than the poll would suggest.
Without a doubt the most usefull source of information for Independence supporters on the internet!
LikeLike