Neil Mackay forgets that this is a dangerous u-turn by Burnham

By Liz S

Neil Mackay posted this in relation to an article he wrote in The Herald:

“With his EU deal, Burnham has shattered the SNP independence strategy.
A declining SNP had one key weapon left: the promise that Indy would take Scotland back into Europe. Now Burnham has snatched that away. Yet still the SNP mock and sneer. They’re out of their depth”.

Really ?

Sorry but this is not a EU deal that will take the UK back into the SM or the CU .

Also what has Burnham actually “snatched away” ?

As Mackay seems to be forgetting to mention that this is a major U-turn in opinion from Andy Burnham , as during his Makerfield by-election campaign, Andy Burnham “pledged not to “re-run” Brexit arguments and stated that he was not proposing that the UK re-join the European Union” Yet now Burnham has suggested that “Britain could eventually re-join the European Union” .

As to Mackay stating that “still the SNP mock and sneer” well are the SNP not subjected regularly to mockery and sneering from the Labour party and also from media like the newspaper that Neil Mackay works for ?

Why are the SNP, to be exempt , as a political party, in them not being allowed to promote the hypocrisy of both the Labour party and Andy Burnham upon Brexit ?

Does Mackay not remember how Scotland were once told that the Brexit vote was a UK wide vote and so then it did not matter how Scotland voted in the EU Referendum.

Also how Scotland was told in 2014, during the referendum campaign on Scottish independence, that “Voting No to keep Scotland in the UK was the surest way to remain in the European Union (EU)”.

Also all that Burnham is currently proposing is a “UK–EU reset deal” and within this reset some things are not permanent , nor are they to be implemented immediately nor in some cases are they yet finalised .

On November 20, 2026, the UK and EU concluded negotiations on a new Youth Experience Scheme allowing 18- to 31-year-olds to work, study, volunteer, au pair, or travel for up to three years, launching no later than January 2030 and “Brussels is pushing for EU students studying in the UK to pay domestic UK rates rather than higher international fees—and wants any fee agreement to cover students regardless of visa route”.

(So it is applicable for 18-31 year olds for a duration of up to only three years, and it is launching no later than January 2030, and also it is not yet resolved in respect to EU students tuition fees matching UK student fees).

Also as part of this reset “Expensive checks on food, farming and plant products moving between Britain and the EU will end, and most of the costly paperwork that has held back British producers will go with them, with rules scheduled to apply from March 1, 2028”.

(So from March 2028 these rules are scheduled to apply).

The SNP have always, as a party and as the Scottish government , been consistent in their commitment to see Scotland , as an independent nation , back within the EU. They have also frequently highlighted the negatives economic and cultural impact of Brexit upon Scotland (and the UK) and yet they were ignored and chastised for doing so. Indeed they were accused of being “Democracy deniers” for wanting to re-join the EU.

Plus is it not really a case of there being many within Labour, and now also Andy Burnham as the new UK PM, who are more than painfully aware that Brexit has totally ducked up their UK State economically , so now the only way that they see as being a way forward for their UK and it’s economy, is in them trying to reverse Brexit.

(Some of these same Labour politicians were adamant, under Starmer, that Brexit was a done deal and so then could not and would not be reopened as an argument under a Labour UK government).

This is not the gotcha moment that Neil Mackay seems to be suggesting it is in respect to the SNP , especially now that Andy Burnham has actually completely U-turned on a previous statement that he made upon EU membership and the UK – that is when he was trying to be re-elected (again) as an MP this year and where he was adamant that Brexit, as an argument and a UK debate, was not to be revisited.

I think and hope many within Scotland have long memories and so they may remember how once they heard :

1) Many Labour MP’s say just after the 2016 EU referendum that they would respect the Brexit vote result as it was a democratic decision made by the British people in 2016 .

2) Then later some other Labour MP’s endorsed what was called “The people’s vote” which was a campaign for a second referendum on Brexit .

3) Then we had Labour win the 2024 UK GE and their new leader Keir Starmer , as the new Labour UK PM , was adamant that the UK would not re-join the EU nor re-join the SM or the CU.

4) Now we have Labour MP’s who were formerly in Starmer’s cabinet saying that Labour should make plans to campaign to re-join the EU.

Yet Neil Mackay dares to somehow try to make this another #SNPBAD issue/moment.

Words do not often fail me but honestly the audacity of some of those within the UK media who try to rewrite history or be very selective in what they decide to include and exclude as details , all just to protect certain politicians and certain political parties , well surely that should see them, as Journalists and as UK media , as those who are named and so then most Definity shamed.

Finally why is it that Labour think that Brexit can be debated again and so then perhaps reversed , yet they are adamant that Scottish independence was settled via the result of the 2014 referendum , which they say was the democratic will of the people of Scotland and so then it cannot be revisited any time soon. Yet it is now 12 years since the Scottish independence referendum (2014) and only 10 years (less time) since the EU referendum (2016) was held ?

Democracy UK style.

Liz S


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One thought on “Neil Mackay forgets that this is a dangerous u-turn by Burnham”

  1. Burnham , or the next ” labour leader ” , will have to continue to appease tha fascist right.
    That will be enough to bring independence .

    Like

Leave a Reply