How Scotland’s Covid Test & Protect system integrated within existing, experienced public health teams in local authorities, succeeded while England’s privatised system ‘cost lives’

The Covid Inquiry on Test & Trace convenes today:

Headlining BBC Breakfast this morning and in the Independent, the above and:

Campaigners have branded the UK’s [sic] Covid-19 test and trace mechanism an “abject failure”, ahead of a major new report into pandemic response measures. Baroness Heather Hallett, chairwoman of the UK Covid-19 Public Inquiry, is set to release her latest findings on Thursday, evaluating the strategies deployed to curb the spread of the virus.

https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/abject-failure-covid-19-test-000133000.html

Yes, no, NHS Scotland gets no mention and you can be sure the media operating in Scotland will either ignore this or use the UK story as if it applied just the same in Scotland.

It didn’t. It really did not.

In August 2020, only months into the pandemic at a crucial time to prevent spread:

From the First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon:

Since the 22nd June, Test & Protect teams have contact traced more than 900 positive cases. Of the people identified as requiring contact tracing, only 3 individuals out of 925 couldn’t be contacted. In other words, teams have traced 99.7% of those positive cases which is a quite remarkable achievement and based on that work, the teams have also traced more than 5 000 contacts and they have been successful in contacting 98.8% of those individuals.

For comparison, between 30 July and 5 August, in England, 79.7% were reached: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nhs-test-and-trace-england-and-coronavirus-testing-uk-statistics-30-july-to-5-august-2020/weekly-statistics-for-nhs-test-and-trace-england-and-coronavirus-testing-uk-30-july-to-5-august

Perhaps of greater informative value for Scots is the news from BBC Manchester that only 53% are being contacted in heavily-infected North-West England: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-manchester-53663510

How was this achieved?

As soon as someone gets a positive test for Covid-19, the contact tracing system will be triggered. The patient will be put in touch with the local contact tracing team to talk through and identify close contacts. At present, most of this will be conducted by telephone calls. Phone apps are in development but Nicola Sturgeon has said that “old-fashioned contact tracing” will be at the heart of the system. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-52533449

The key to the system’s success has been its integration with existing, experience public health teams in local authorities and the link with the named person who might be infected.

Professor’s Sridhar and Bauld have spoken of the common sense employed here. Professor Pennington and his contacts in the Scottish media have been silent on this. Had there been any failures in the Scottish system might we have heard of them?

In sharp contrast, the Con Government in England, supported by our own Tories, bypassed those same local authorities to privatise the system. We know now from Leicester and from brewing hot-spots in Bradford, and in up to 25 other locations, that these for-profit operators have not provided local authorities with the data they needed to act.

Two months after Scotland and after bad press and outcry from several mayors, Johnson and Hancock have turned. In the Observer today:

The health secretary, Matt Hancock, has bowed to pressure from councils, which demanded full access to the names and data of people in their areas who tested positive for Covid-19, and those with whom they have been in contact, in another major government U-turn. Local authorities and public health officials have been complaining for weeks that they are being hampered in efforts to combat and prevent local outbreaks by lack of access to “named patient data” which would allow them to get straight to the sources of local outbreaks. Now the Observer has been told that Hancock, who has insisted repeatedly that local authorities have all the information they need from the track and trace system, is set to give way and allow access to the named data as well other information already provided, such as postcodes, so long as strict data protection rules and conditions are followed. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/jul/18/matt-hancock-in-new-u-turn-on-coronavirus-testing-data

Did they only have postcodes before? Really? Who thought that could work?

Might BBC Scotland’s Disclosure team now follow up one or two folk in Annan who have been ‘traumatised’ by the SNP system’s contempt for their human rights? Might the local Tories feature? They have plans for human rights legislation don’t they?

Finally, ‘cost lives?’

See:

and:


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One thought on “How Scotland’s Covid Test & Protect system integrated within existing, experienced public health teams in local authorities, succeeded while England’s privatised system ‘cost lives’”

  1. The unionist media do NOT want to hear that Scotland ( under the SNP ) had better results during Covid , so they will consistently ignore any positive stats . from here .
    Rather , they will lump in Scotland with England and call it UK stats . so obscuring any statistical differences which might show England in a bad light !

    When will more people in Scotland realise that the UK media are NOT Scotland friendly ? Putin and Trump get better press than the Scottish Government .

    Like

Leave a Reply