STV accuse Stephen Flynn of paving over storm drains in Largs five years earlier when he should have been in Westminster. Experts say such storms cannot be fully defended against

Did the young STV reporter with the Ulster accent think she was speaking to a local councillor tonight in Largs when prompted by a chocolate shop owner, she accused Stephen Flynn, Transport Minister, personally and directly of having paved over storm drains.

The shop owner, left, with her party leader:

The resurfacing of the road outside the shop was resurfaced by Amey in 2021 with further work after more flooding in 2025.

Might the flooding this time be due to the intensity of this storm?

Yes — the intensity of Storm Boelo was almost certainly a major factor in the scale of the flooding on Largs Main Street this time.

Storm Boelo (overnight 24–25 October 2026) brought:

  • Gusts widely exceeding 80 mph, with peaks of 84–85 mph in western Scotland.
  • Heavy rainfall that caused both surface-water and coastal flooding across parts of the west coast (including Largs, Dumbarton and Rothesay).
  • Significant storm surge and high tides. Reports and the shop owner herself described the tide as “incredibly high” and the water levels as the highest she had seen in 26 years of trading. Seawater was reported flooding buildings and the seafront; debris was washed up, and further high tides were expected later in the day.⁠

Toni Dawson of Geraldo’s explicitly described this event as far worse than previous ones and noted the extreme tide. Other local businesses also reported seawater or extreme flooding not limited to the previous rainwater runoff issues.

This Storm Boelo event, however, combined heavy rain with a substantial coastal surge and high tide. That is a different (and more extreme) driver than the previous surface-water problems alone. Coastal towns on the Ayrshire and wider west-coast frontage were widely affected by the same combination of wind, rain and elevated sea levels.

In short, while the pre-existing drainage shortcomings may have made the situation worse, the exceptional intensity of this storm, especially the high tide and storm surge, is the dominant reason the flooding reached the scale reported on 25 October.

Would further flood defences have prevented flooding from a storm of this intensity?

Further flood defences would likely have reduced the risk and severity, but it is unlikely they would have fully prevented flooding from a storm of Storm Boelo’s intensity. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-15665-3

Is the problem the closeness of the shopping street to the shore unlike in some other towns such as Ayr?

Yes — the closeness of Largs’ main shopping street to the shore is a fundamental reason it is more vulnerable to coastal flooding than towns such as Ayr. https://www.sepa.org.uk/environment/water/flooding/check-your-flood-risk/

14 thoughts on “STV accuse Stephen Flynn of paving over storm drains in Largs five years earlier when he should have been in Westminster. Experts say such storms cannot be fully defended against”

  1. That is not Stephen Flynn in thst photo for Starters When would Stephen Flynn have anything to do with the pavements in Largs AYRSHIRE he works in London and Lives in Aberdeen LIES

    Like

  2. Do journos do any science these days?

    The storm is an extreme low pressure event which means the water level is able to rise, and combined with a high tide probably 5m or so and 80 mph winds what do they think is going to be the outcome ?

    Like

  3. As one would expect given Local Authority responsibilities, there is much information on the North Ayrshire Council website regarding flood risk, mitigation and protection.

    This includes ‘Interim Progress Report on the 2nd Ayrshire Local Flood Risk Management Plan’ published by North Ayrshire Council, December 2025 – https://www.north-ayrshire.gov.uk/Document-library/local-flood-risk-management-plan-progress.pdf

    The document recounts the impacts of prior storms. It also itemises the local actions being taken by the Council with regard to flood protection, including in Largs and Saltcoats. It appears from this report that the work decided upon by the Council was on track in December last for completion.

    On Storm Gerrit (December 2023) – ‘… contributed to flooding throughout North Ayrshire but the towns of Millport, West Kilbride, Largs and Fairlie experienced the most significant impacts.’ And: ‘ In Largs, various culvert improvements had been assessed previously but these assessments concluded that the improvement options were not economically viable. Instead, self-help measures should be promoted to affected residents.’

    On Storm Eowyn (January 2025) – ‘… resulted in property damage in Saltcoats due to wave overtopping’ and the report notes ‘.. this was an extreme event and the impacts could not be predicted.’

    Like

  4. Apparently the woman who owns the shop posted on Facebook that they were closing early because of the approaching storm and had sandbags ready to put down.

    Like

  5. I don’t know the woman in question or her political affiliations or what she said but I do know she has a valid complaint. Every since that storm drain was tarmacked over a large puddle regularly develops outside her shop. It does not require a named storm for this to happen, only some rain. She has been complaining about this since it happened but neither the Council or Amey seem to accept responsibility for fixing it. So if she is angry at having her shop flooded again I can completely understand. He may not be to blame but maybe Stephen Flynn could help solve the problem.

    Like

    1. “She has been complaining about this since it happened but neither the Council or Amey seem to accept responsibility for fixing it.” Perhaps it’s a bit more ‘nuanced’ than that?

      From the BBC News website’s Scotland section on 16 November 2025: ‘Flood-hit shop issues closure warning after drain covered in tarmac.’

      We’re told: ‘The owner of a seaside town shop fears she will have to “throw in the towel” on her business over flooding issues triggered when a nearby storm drain was covered in tarmac. Over the past three years any sort of heavy downpour brings water running from the A78 road directly into Geraldo’s on Main Street, Largs. Toni Dawson has run the tourist shop for about 25 years but is unsure how much longer she can continue unless a solution is found.’

      It’s pleasing that Ms Dawson seems to have been able to ‘continue;’ for almost a further year. Was a solution found?

      The BBC article expands: ‘Ms Dawson said the issue dates back to resurfacing work which was carried out by road maintenance company Amey. The firm said it was urgently seeking a solution.’

      And is this from the BBC evidence the responsibility being taken by the company to deliver a solution? The BBC reports: ‘An Amey spokesperson said: “Following a site meeting, a Category 1 repair was raised to reinstate the affected gully, and this has now been issued to our operations team for completion as a priority. In addition, a further gully on the adjacent footpath is being inspected as part of our scheduled route inspection, and will be cleared if required.

      “We appreciate the impact that flooding can have on road users and local residents, and we are continuing to monitor the area closely while works progress. Our priority is to ensure the drainage system is functioning effectively to reduce the risk of further surface water issues.” Both the council and Transport Scotland confirmed the road was the responsibility of Amey.’

      The same BBC article gives more background based on the shop owner’s remarks: ‘After starting the business, she had flooding difficulties early on caused by the premises being so near the seafront. Those problems STOPPED once the nearby sea wall defences were improved. But since the road was resurfaced in late 2021, the shop has faced constant issues triggered by extreme weather.’ (my emphasis)

      So based on the November 2025 BBC Scotland piece, (i) ‘sea wall defences’ had already been build which brought notable improvements; and (ii) Amy is reported as taking responsibility and acting to deliver a remedy. So perhaps more nuanced?

      The BBC News website’s Scotland section provided a short video clip of the recent flooding in Largs (see https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/videos/c977pkdjm0z8o ). A female voice states (in terms) ‘Worst flooding I’ve seen in 36 years’, referring to the state of the flood water impacting her shop.

      Now to the Scottish Government. From the New Civil Engineer magazine (May 2, 2024) ‘North Ayrshire £48M flood scheme offshore works complete and £4.6M sea wall installed’.

      ‘North Ayrshire Council has seen milestones on two flood coastal with offshore works completed on the £48M Millport Flood Protection Scheme and construction of the £4.6M Largs sea wall entering its final stage. The council said the Scottish Government was CONTRIBUTING 80% towards the overall costs of the scheme, with the council meeting the rest.’ Taking appropriate responsibility?

      The article goes on: ‘… also within North Ayrshire Council district, a £4.6M, 300m seawall is nearing completion at the town of Largs between Aubery Crescent and the RNLI station. A new precast concrete seawall has been installed in front of an existing seawall and steps to the beach have been replaced which the council said improved accessibility for visitors. The existing seawall was built in the 1970s and repeated exposure to seawater had led to its deterioration.’

      This specialist publication also reports: ”The new seawall should provide “optimum protection” and support against wave activity and coastal erosion, according to the council.’

      So more evidence of recent action, and recent taking of responsibility! Did the Council opt to spend its and Scottish Government funds amounting to over £50m in the wrong way or places in order to address the flood risks of Largs? Or was the recent storm of such an intensity, direction and timing with respect to tides that regrettably Largs was bound to suffer due to its geography?

      From the above, it seems yet to be shown that the alleged problems associated with Amey’s resurfacing work had a material effect on what Largs experienced in recent days. Perhaps some conflation of two distinct issues going on here – for whatever reason?

      Like

      1. Stewart, I have lived in Largs for many years and have seen the improvement in the sea wall that have improved and reduced flooding problems for the homes and businesses near the pier. But this a problem caused by a stupid decision to tarmac over a drain. So the water that would have just drained away now regularly forms a huge puddle on the road and on the pavement. This was done years ago and no solution as yet. That is not a nuanced failure it is just a failure.
        I am disappointed that you chose to double down on your cheap shot insinuation that this shop owner was only complaining because she a Tory when a real problem exists. I also find it a little ironic that you quote BBC articles at me when you spend a lot of your time on this site (rightly) criticising the accuracy of BBC output. BTW I am a supporter of this site but cannot support your view in this instance.

        Like

  6. Sorry, but I have made NO ‘cheap shot insinuation’ concerning any individual’s political affiliation in my two btl contributions to this thread!

    The legitimacy of pulling quotes from BBC News reports is a broader issue. Happy to leave others to judge the appropriateness or otherwise of my use of references to BBC material in this particular instance.

    Like

Leave a Reply