Utterly stupid scaremongering headline on knife crime from BBC Scotland’s David Cowan

From BBC Scotland today:

Three senseless killings in the space of six months, all involving teenagers and bladed weapons, have raised concern over youth-related knife crime in Scotland to a level not seen for many years. The deaths of Amen Teklay, Kayden Moy and John McNab last year left many wondering whether the country was going backwards to the shameful time when Scotland endured one of the worst homicide rates in western Europe.

The above cluster took place in 2005 with the last in September. Despite two very warm and dry periods this year, there have been no such cases since then.

Reporter, David Cowan, then quickly goes on to admit the truth but the damage is done:

However, the reality is that most of the publicly available statistics on youth-related violence and knife crime tell a different story. Official data shows a reduction in the number of teenagers involved in violence, caught with blades, or referred to the Children’s Reporter over knife offences.

Then, desperately trying to keep the anxiety level up, he writes:

But the number of under-18s involved in attempted murders bucked that downward trend and any flicker of optimism will be of no comfort whatsoever to the people who’ve lost loved ones through a teenager wielding a knife.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cgk4xz8lxe2o

The evidence for the above comes from a 3 month-only report with no actual data nor methodology offered. https://www.spa.police.uk/spa-media/2rjhb1bf/item-2-2-ps-q1-ytd-performance-report.pdf

So, this dodgy piece of work gets headlined but BBC Scotland did not report:


Discover more from The 'Unstoppable' Talking-up Scotland

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.