One more reason why Scotland’s media need to stop watching England

In the Guardian today:

Senior government officials have raised “urgent” concerns about the mass expansion of rapid coronavirus testing, estimating that as few as 2% to 10% of positive results may be accurate in places with low Covid rates, such as London. However, leaked emails seen by the Guardian show that senior officials are now considering scaling back the widespread testing of people without symptoms, due to a growing number of false positives. On 9 April, the day everyone in England was able to order twice-weekly lateral flow device (LFD) tests, Dyson wrote: “As of today, someone who gets a positive LFD result in (say) London has at best a 25% chance of it being a true positive, but if it is a self-reported test potentially as low as 10% (on an optimistic assumption about specificity) or as low as 2% (on a more pessimistic assumption).”

But from the BBC yesterday:

Most positive rapid coronavirus tests taken since 8 March appear to have returned a correct result, according to data seen by the BBC. Analysis of data from Public Health England shows 82% sent off for a confirmatory PCR test returned the same positive result. All secondary school pupils in England have been asked to carry out two tests a week since schools reopened. There had been concerns that many would have to self-isolate needlessly. But this data suggests these fears may be unfounded.

So, they don’t have a clue. Rapid or lateral flow tests are 2% accurate or 82% accurate depending on how and where the research was done.

In 2020, the BMJ and Professor Pollock warned us that these tests were unreliable and were being used by politicians as a tool to win public support.

Only just over a week ago, Scotland’s media were implying, as they love to do, that Scotland was falling behind England on mass testing of this kind:


This, like the demands for earlier emergence from lockdown measures or faster vaccination of those less at risk, just reinforces the stupidity and potential damage that might be done by the Scottish media watching what the incompetent Johnson regime does and then pressing the Scottish Government to follow.

How many times have we heard questions at the Scottish Covid briefings along the lines of: ‘People in England are getting this. Do you have plans to do the same here?

Not just an agenda but also lazy journalism.

2 thoughts on “One more reason why Scotland’s media need to stop watching England

  1. OT slightly John, but on inyref2 this morning this popped up… Following on from the Kent variant which wreaked such havoc in the the UQ and beyond, this gives me an odd feeling of dejavu…

    Agreed on the “Not just an agenda but also lazy journalism”, but one so readily disguises the other – The bumbling Boris for instance is an artifice amplified by a compliant media, it is not his laziness which condemned so many in England to an early demise but utter ruthlessness…

    Liked by 2 people

  2. The media in Scotland hasn’t moved on from imperial days when what happened in England was the yard stick by which the rest of the world was measured.
    Perhaps that is because of the people who own it.
    If they want to judge Scotland against best practice,then England is not the place they should be looking at.

    Liked by 3 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.