Poll suggesting to a gammon that majority of Scots support mass detention and deportation has same sampling flaw as those suggesting a No majority in a referendum on independence

Professor John Robertson OBA Not for the first time, one time half-decent journo, now full-time Tory Gammon, Ian Macwhirter, cannot conceal his glee when he thinks he’s found evidence that Scots are just as nasty as Essex Tories. He bases his latest on the Sunday Times/Norstat poll on 22-25 September 2025, revealing that 60% of the sample (1 010) support mass detention sand deportation of those who arrive in the UK, without permission, for example on small boats? There’s a problem. The sample of 1 010 has been adjusted, ‘weighted‘, to match the vote in the 2014 referendum, 11 years … Continue reading Poll suggesting to a gammon that majority of Scots support mass detention and deportation has same sampling flaw as those suggesting a No majority in a referendum on independence

‘Proud’ Englishman’s attempt to patronise Scots is embarrassing afterthought

By Liz S On the BBC website Scottish Politics page. Starmer expresses pride in saltire as he vows UK ‘renewal’ Well actually the content of this article specifies that he , in his conference speech, stated “”I’m not just proud of the union jack and the cross of St George, I’m also proud of the saltire, proud of the red dragon, proud of our union.” So not just noting “pride” in the Saltire then….and also what Union is it that he is referring to ? Also if he is so “proud” of the Saltire then why is it that he only produces a video every year on ‘X’ (formerly Twitter) on St George’s day and declares what he thinks it means … Continue reading ‘Proud’ Englishman’s attempt to patronise Scots is embarrassing afterthought

As the Guardian reports cancer treatment failures in NHS England how Scotland hits 95% target and outperforms it to save thousands but ‘your’ media keep quiet

Professor John Robertson OBA In the Guardian today, the above. Looking at the most recent statistics: NHS Scotland In Q2 2025 (April-June), 95.3% of 7 461 patients started treatment within 31 days from decision to treat, beating the 95% target, and 69.9% of patients started treatment within 62 days from urgent suspicion of cancer. https://publichealthscotland.scot/publications/cancer-waiting-times/cancer-waiting-times-1-april-to-30-june-2025/ NHS England In July 2025, 92.4% of patients started treatment within 31 days and 69.2% of patients started treatment within 62 days. https://news.cancerresearchuk.org/2025/09/24/cancer-waiting-times-latest-updates-and-analysis/ So, NHS Scotland performing significantly better and remember that around 3% difference means around 250 more patients treated on time in Scotland, in one quarter, and around 2 500 more … Continue reading As the Guardian reports cancer treatment failures in NHS England how Scotland hits 95% target and outperforms it to save thousands but ‘your’ media keep quiet

A tale of BBC Scotland’s response to Scottish Government press releases – how widespread, how blatant is bias by omission becoming?

By stewartb Each and every working day at 1600 hours, the Scottish Government sends out an e-mail headed ‘Daily news update’. This collates all press releases issued that day, presumably in part as an aid to journalists. You will often find one or more of the day’s topics referred to here on TuS. But by BBC Scotland or the wider mainstream media in Scotland? Not so much!  Is amplifying positive news from the present Scottish Government too much of a threat to Unionist politicians? Whilst the nature of BBC journalism in Scotland is well known to readers of this blog, … Continue reading A tale of BBC Scotland’s response to Scottish Government press releases – how widespread, how blatant is bias by omission becoming?

Scotland’s own NHS app can do more than Mr Streeting’s app!

Professor John Robertson OBA Thanks to Anonymous for alerting us to this: Scotland’s own app can do more than Mr Streeting’s app! Following initial roll-out, MyCare will be expanded to hospital-based services, BEFORE including other areas of the health and social care system, including GP practices, pharmacy, social work and social care. https://www.gov.scot/news/scotlands-new-health-and-social-care-app/ The NHS England app does claim to include GP services and pharmacies but has no link to social work or social care. https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/social-prescribing-reference-guide-and-technical-annex-for-primary-care-networks/ Talking-up Scotland’s special crowd funder has closed but you can support at any time at: https://www.crowdfunder.co.uk/checkout/help-talking-up-scotland-tell-truth-about-scotland/payment/nBQxjVzq/details or by direct bank transfer method – Bernadette/John … Continue reading Scotland’s own NHS app can do more than Mr Streeting’s app!

NHS Scotland Hits Five-Year High for operations but who will tell you that?

From the Scottish government’s news site YESTERDAY and, as far as we can see reported by no other media outlet than the Highland Times. Thanks to cuckooshoe for alerting us to this: The number of operations performed in July was the highest in five years, according to Public Health Scotland statistics published today. The data shows that 23,470 operations were carried out in July, an 8.9% increase compared to July of last year. This figure is the highest since February 2020, before the COVID-19 pandemic. Over the past 12 months to July 2025, a total of 265,060 operations were performed, … Continue reading NHS Scotland Hits Five-Year High for operations but who will tell you that?

NO ONE anywhere should be reviled , hated or indeed killed just because of their religion or their beliefs

By Liz S Post the attacks on the synagogue yesterday……. “Sir Keir Starmer has promised to do “everything” in his power to protect Jewish people as he said Britain must defeat antisemitic hate“…… However what is Starmer doing to “protect Muslim people within his Britain” as surely “Britain” must also “defeat Islamophobia hate” as well ? He also said that “hatred against Jews is rising once again” but surely he also recognises the same is applicable “against Muslims”….. Let’s be honest here…. much of that hatred against Muslims stems from the language being used by people like Starmer, also other politicians (including pretend ones … Continue reading NO ONE anywhere should be reviled , hated or indeed killed just because of their religion or their beliefs

Latest data shows just 1.8% of the Scottish population used private healthcare for inpatient and day case admissions but STV find a private healthcare boom

Professor John Robertson OBA The above from September 2023, shows private healthcare providers (red) and MPs taking money from them to push their interests (blue £), notably then only one in Scotland – Ian Murray, Edinburgh South (Labour). https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewer?mid=1_vYkm4Yb_3r1SCl76qvgdR6zwqqB4u4&femb=1&ll=54.52217059297223%2C-2.3420011625000114&z=6 STV today has the above and what is essentially advertising for the Elanic Hospital in Glasgow. Typically, only at the very end of long piece do we see: A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “Latest data shows just 1.8% of the Scottish population used private healthcare for inpatient and day case admissions. telling the reader that they have been reading a pack … Continue reading Latest data shows just 1.8% of the Scottish population used private healthcare for inpatient and day case admissions but STV find a private healthcare boom

How Wes Streeting’s NHS app has failed the people of England

Professor John Robertson OBA In the Times on 30 September 2025, the above and: Wes Streeting has attacked the SNP over its “shameful” failure to launch an NHS app for Scottish patients. The UK health secretary told the Labour conference that while progress was being made in England and Wales on tackling waiting lists and harnessing innovative new technologies in the health service, standards were continuing to deteriorate in Scotland. He highlighted the failure of the Nationalist government to launch an app for the health service — one has been in use in England for the past six years. Oooh, … Continue reading How Wes Streeting’s NHS app has failed the people of England

Dr Iain Kennedy linked to Labour campaign and Prof Curtice might be underestimating the intelligence of fleeing Labour voters

Professor John Robertson OBA, Former Faculty Research Ethics Chair The word ‘ethics’ does not appear in Prof Curtice’s CV. Should I see if Dr Kennedy has any such interests? Should I check if the BMA ever considers the ethical dimensions of their surveys? I did. SFA. In the Herald today – Labour is losing ground in Scotland as NHS blame game bites, two things are intriguing. The big one is about the NHS performance so I’ll get the lesser one out of the way first: With mounting waiting lists, staff shortages, and bed-blocking crises, Scottish Labour has made the state of the … Continue reading Dr Iain Kennedy linked to Labour campaign and Prof Curtice might be underestimating the intelligence of fleeing Labour voters